20 Albrecht Ritschl, _Die Entstehung der altkatholischen Kirche, eine kirchen- und dogmengeschichtliche Monographie,_ 1850, 622 pp.; 2nd ed., 1857, 605 pp. 21 Gotthard Viktor Lechler, _Das apostolische und das nachapostolische Zeitalter mit Rücksicht auf Unterschied und Einheit in Lehre und Leben_ ( . . . with special reference to their difference and unity in life and doctrine), 1st ed., 1852; 2nd ed., 1857, 536 pp. The portion dealing with Paul is pp. 33-154; in the 3rd ed., 1885 (635 pp.) Paul is treated on pp. 269-407. In the first two editions the whole of the Pauline epistles are regarded as genuine; in the third the author no longer ventures to treat the Pastorals as on the same footing with the other Epistles. The very clearly and comprehensively stated problem is printed at the beginning. 22 _Die paulinische Rechtfertigungslehre,_ 1853, 219 pp. 23 In 1850, _Beiträge zur Erklärung der Korinthesbriefe,_ pp. 139-185. Continued in 1852, pp. 1-40 and 535-574. In 1855, _Die beiden Briefe an die Thessalonicher; ihre Achtheit und Bedeutung für die Lehre der Parusie Christi, pp._ 141-168 ( . . . their genuineness and their significance for the doctrine of the parousia of Christ). In 1857, _Über Zweck und Gedankengang des Römerbriefs nebst der Erörterung einiger paulinischen Begriffe,_ pp. 60-108 and 184-209 (“On the Purpose and the Argument of Romans, with a Discussion of certain Pauline Conceptions.”) 24 _Paulus der Apostel Jesu Christi,_ 2nd ed., edited by Zeller, 1866-1867, vol. i. 469 pp., revised by Baur; vol. ii. 376 pp. contains a reprint of the chapter on Paul’s doctrine from the first edition. 25 _Vorlesungen über neutestamentliche Theologie._ Published by Ferdinand Friedrich Baur, 1864, 407 pp. Pages 128-207 deal with the doctrinal system of Paul. NOTES FOR CHAPTER III FROM BAUR TO HOLTZMANN 26 _Die Pastoralbriefe kritisch und exegetisch behandelt,_ 1880, 504 pp. Adolf Harnack (in _Die Chronologie der altchristlichen Literatur bis Eusebius,_ vol. i., 1897, 732 pp.—on Paul, 233-239) is disposed to regard the personal notices of the Pastorals as genuine with the aid of the hypothesis of the second imprisonment. 27 _Kritik der Epheser- und Kolosserbriefe,_ 1872, 338 pp. 28 _Einleitung in das Neue Testament,_ 1885; 2nd ed., 1886; 3rd ed., 1892. Second Thessalonians, Ephesians, and the Pastoral Epistles, spurious; Colossians, worked over. A similar critical stand-point is occupied by Adolf Jülicher, _Einleitung in das Neue Testament,_ 1894, 404 pp. The Pauline Epistles are treated in pp. 19-128.