Penal Methods of the Middle Ages: Criminals, Witches, LunaticsIves, George Burnham
History
Penal Methods of the Middle Ages: Criminals, Witches, Lunatics
Ives, George Burnham
Punishment
Speaking of a particular case, Mr. H. L. Stephen[558] quotes Campbell as
follows: “... During the trial the imposture practised by the
prosecutors was detected and exposed. Hales’ motives were most laudable;
but he furnished a memorable instance of the mischief originating from
superstition. He was afraid of an acquittal or a pardon, lest
countenance should be given to a disbelief in witchcraft, which he
considered tantamount to disbelief in Christianity.” Glanvil[559]
follows on the same side, arguing with great ingenuity from the
scriptural point of view (for instance, in dealing with certain
doctrines as to the fate of unbaptized children, p. 22). “The question
whether there are witches or not,” he begins in Part ii., “is not a
matter of vain speculation or of indifferent moment, but an inquiry of
very great and weighty importance. For on the resolution of it depends
the authority of our laws, and, which is more, our religion, in its main
doctrines, is nearly concerned.”
And what may be called the religious belief in witches[560]—a very
different thing from the torturing of them—outlived the penal laws
concerning them.[561] The Rev. John Brown of Haddington (1703–1791)[561]
complained of the repeal of King James’s Act,[562] and even John Wesley
(1722–1787) declared that giving up witchcraft is, in effect, giving up
the Bible.[563] On page 366 of the journal[564] which he edited we read:
“With my latest breath will I bear testimony against giving up to
infidels one great proof of the invisible world. I mean that of
witchcraft and apparitions, confirmed by the testimony of all
ages”;[565] and Huxley[566] alluded to a contemporary clergyman who had
been preaching diabolical agency. Nor did the actual persecutions cease
altogether, and though the last legal trial in England took place in
1712[567] (the last execution in Europe is given by Lecky[568] as
occurring in Switzerland in 1782; another authority mentions Posen,[569]
with date 1793), sporadic outrages continued in the country, and persist
in a modified form to the present day.[570] At Clonmel, Ireland, in
1895,[571] a poor old woman was placed upon the kitchen fire by her own
family and burned, so that she died from the effects.[572] But what were
once pious customs and duties had at length become crimes, and the chief
mover in this latest witch trial got (to the best of my recollection)
twenty years’ penal servitude.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account