A short time after I had published in Harper's Magazine the sketch of General Thomas, of which this is a revised edition, I received many letters from old friends complaining that I had not done him justice in using the expression "Thomas originates nothing," and many were the instances quoted showing his originality of mind and plans. None of the arguments or examples given were convincing, however, and I have left the expression unchanged. One of these complainants stated that General Thomas was the originator of the plan to go through Snake Creek Gap in order to get upon Joe Johnston's rear and flank; but I am inclined to think this an error. The writer narrated that a few days after starting on the Atlanta campaign in May, 1864, Sherman, having thoroughly reconnoitred Rocky Face Ridge, the defensive line of the enemy, decided that it was necessary to storm and carry the position. Sitting one day on the railroad bank in front of Buzzard Roost Gap, he confided this opinion to General Thomas. "It can't be done, general," Thomas answered; "the ridge can not be carried." "But it must be," said the impetuous Sherman, with his usual petulance. General Thomas repeated his observation. "But then we can't stay here," urged Sherman; "we must go ahead--we can't stop here. There is nothing left but to assault the ridge." "Have you tried every other means, general? Can't we go around them?" asked Thomas, at the same time unfolding his map. "Yes, yes, we have tried all other means."