Peter's Rock in Mohammed's Flood, from St. Gregory the Great to St. Leo IIIAllies, T. W. (Thomas William)
Islamic
Peter's Rock in Mohammed's Flood, from St. Gregory the Great to St. Leo III
Allies, T. W. (Thomas William)
Christianity and other religions -- Islam; Church history -- Middle Ages, 600-1500; Papacy; Papacy -- History
“Again we ask, how is it, when in this Scripture of yours he enjoined to
do nothing, and to receive nothing without witnesses, that you did not ask
him, first show by witnesses that you are a prophet, and have come forth
from God, and what Scripture bears witness to you? They are mute through
shame. Since you may not marry without witnesses, nor market, nor possess,
nor take an ass or beast of burden without witness. Wives, indeed, you
have, and possessions, and asses, and all the rest through witnesses.
Faith alone and Scripture you have without a witness. He who gave you this
has no security whatever. No witness preceding him is known: but he
received it asleep. They call us associators, because we bring in an
associate to God, when we say that Christ is the Son of God, and God. We
reply, prophets and Scripture have handed this down to us. You, as you
assert, acknowledge prophets. If we are wrong in saying that Christ is Son
of God, it is they who have taught it and delivered it to us.”
The objection here made in general, that Mohammed had no witness to his
mission, and none to the assertion that his Scripture came from God, has
received no answer. Indeed, not only is there no witness that the Koran
was given by God, or by the agency of the prophet Gabriel, but the
condition in which it was left by Mohammed at his death supplies the
strongest internal evidence that the Scripture was an imposture. This is
the account given by the historian of the present day, who has used thirty
years of his life to study, and compare Mohammedan writers on their
prophet.(107)
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account