Peter's Rock in Mohammed's Flood, from St. Gregory the Great to St. Leo IIIAllies, T. W. (Thomas William)
Islamic
Peter's Rock in Mohammed's Flood, from St. Gregory the Great to St. Leo III
Allies, T. W. (Thomas William)
Christianity and other religions -- Islam; Church history -- Middle Ages, 600-1500; Papacy; Papacy -- History
“The Koran is the Arabic name for the Mohammedan Bible, or collection of
discourses held by Mohammed in the name of God, in his quality as inspired
prophet, which, as he asserts, were partly communicated through the angel
Gabriel, partly revealed to him immediately by God through dreams or
visions. But the Koran is not, like the Bible, a book drawn up in
chronological order, or according to the variety of its contents, but a
mixing up of hymns, prayers, dogmas, sermons, casual writings, narratives,
legends, laws, and orders of the day, with many repetitions and
contradictions. This comes because Mohammed himself made no collection of
the revelations given singly to him during a course of twenty-three years.
It is probable that it was not even his wish that all of them should be
kept, since a great number of them had only a transitory meaning. Likewise
he had undertaken so many alterations in his doctrines and laws that he
had reason to shrink from handing them all down to posterity. In fine he
certainly wished to retain up to his death free room for modifications and
additions which might be necessary. But after his death all fragments of
the revelation were thrown together, even when they had been repealed by
others, or were already issued in different form. All portions of the
Koran, scattered in different hands, inscribed on parchment, palm-leaves,
bones, stones, or other rough materials for writing, were collected—or
even such as lived only in the remembrance of his companions and
disciples—and were divided, mostly without regard to their contents, or
the time at which they had been revealed, into greater or smaller
chapters, Suras; and thus the actual Koran, with all its defects, was
made. It is only by an accurate knowledge of the circumstances of
Mohammed’s life, and the language of the Koran, in some degree possible to
restore the chronological order of its several parts. By the help of
Mohammed’s Arabian biographers, some of whom go back so far as the second
century of the Mohammedan era, it is possible to determine the date of
such sections as relate to historical events. Where this is not the case,
the character and form of the revelation serve to direct. Mohammed in his
first time appears more as a reformer, later as the founder of a new
religion, at last as prince and legislator. In the first period he was
carried away by inward enthusiasm: his language has a rhythmical movement,
with true poetic colouring. In the second period a calmer consideration
takes the place of excited fancy; he is more rhetorician than poet: his
words spring rather from an understanding wide awake, not sparkling, as
before, with warmth of heart. In the third period the language sinks to
sober prose, not only in ordaining laws, issuing injunctions, or narrating
campaigns, but when he paints, as before, God’s Almightiness, the wonders
of creation, the terrors of the last judgment, or the joys of paradise.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account