"There's a good background for you, Stokely. It faces the lock, and I
imagine you'll want to do the same."
He swung the flashlight slowly around. There were several piles of
boulders standing about, and Archer indicated two of them, each about
120 degrees from the first.
"Evans and I can take those two positions. That way we'll form a
triangle, each of us about 40 feet from the ship, and in plain sight
of the others--that is, _if_ we develop that fatal glow. In any case,
Stokely, I think you can depend on us staying put until we find out,
since--"
"And then what happens?" Stokely demanded impatiently. "How do we find
out--without trusting each other? The whole set-up sounds silly to me!"
"It's my life, too," Archer reminded him. "And in case you're in any
doubt, I don't trust you, either. Here's the plan: As you know, all of
us were exposed within a very few minutes of each other. That means,
according to our late friend, the doctor, that in ten to 12 minutes
from now--perhaps a few minutes longer--one or more of us should show
the symptomatic aura.
"Now there's the point: _one or more_ of us. There's an excellent
chance we won't all show it. Allowing an adequate margin, the next 20
minutes should reveal who has the infection and who hasn't. I propose
that at the end of that time each of us in turn announces, not which
of the others shows it but simply whether he sees the aura at all. He
doesn't tell whether one or both of the others shows it, but merely
whether _at least one_ does."
"What good would that do anybody?" asked Stokely glumly.
"None, in itself. But you forget that all of us will be reporting. For
instance, supposing Evans says he sees it, but I don't show it, or vice
versa--two very distinct possibilities. Then you'd know that the only
place Evans could have seen it--"
"What if he were lying?" Stokely put in sharply.
"That's the general idea in back of the whole scheme. He couldn't get
away with it. If he said he saw it and didn't, it could only mean that
neither you nor I showed it. In that case--which is one of the lesser
possibilities, incidentally--I'd be led into the same error that you
would. But it would then be very much to our mutual benefit to compare
notes before taking any injection.
"If he said he didn't see it, and either of us had it, the other would
know he was lying. If we can't trust each other to tell the truth, we
can't very well depend on each other to back up our lies--especially
when there is everything to lose by it. If you knew Evans was lying
about me, how would you know whether he was telling the truth about
you?"
"Now listen!" protested Evans, who seemed to be shivering as much with
fear as with the cold, "you guys talk like you expected me to pull a
fast one. Hell, it's complicated enough if we all tell the truth--don't
worry about me!"
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account