Phylogeny of the Waxwings and Allied Birds — John Shaqi
Phylogeny of the Waxwings and Allied BirdsArvey, M. Dale (Martin Dale)
Science
Phylogeny of the Waxwings and Allied Birds
Arvey, M. Dale (Martin Dale)
Bombycillidae -- Phylogeny; Waxwings -- Phylogeny
In comparatively recent geological time, two basic lines developed
from the Bombycilline stock, the future _B. garrula_ and _B.
cedrorum_. Possibly _garrula_ originally was isolated in Europe and
Asia, and later came into contact with _B. cedrorum_, following the
time at which the two species were genetically well differentiated. It
appears certain that _B. japonica_ was an offshoot of the Bombycilline
stock at an early time, since it has characteristics that seem
relatively unspecialized. It possibly was isolated in the Orient.
Structural affinities of _Dulus_ and _Bombycilla_ are more pronounced
than are those of _Dulus_ and _Ptilogonys_, for example. Many of the
structural features of _Dulus_ parallel those of _Phainoptila_, and it
seems likely that the Dulinae were separated early in the history of
the family, perhaps as an isolated offshoot of the early migratory
Bombycillinae.
CONCLUSIONS
Nomenclature, as used by a taxonomist, should of course indicate
affinities as well as apply a name, and the rank of the family should
be applied to a structural unit based on common anatomical characters
that are more fundamental than, in my opinion, are those used by
Ridgway (1904) in proposing family status for the silky flycatchers
and the palm-chats. The characters in the diagnosis (page 478) of the
family Bombycillidae are common features regarded as warranting a
single family unit for the waxwings, silky flycatchers, and
palm-chats. The differences in morphology used by previous workers to
characterize each of these groups: (1) the silky flycatchers; (2)
waxwings and; (3) palm-chats are regarded as more properly characters
of only subfamily rank.
The existing coloration of the species of the Bombycillidae appears to
have been acquired relatively late, geologically speaking. The three
subfamilies responded to ecological stimuli in three different ways,
and the resulting color patterns are unlike in the three groups.
Dulinae to this day have a color pattern that is most like the
ancestral color pattern, and this is recapitulated in the juvenal
plumage of the Bombycillinae before they attain their adult plumage.
Consideration of the geographic distribution of the species of the
family indicates that the center of origin of the family Bombycillidae
was south of the present range of the waxwings (subfamily
Bombycillinae). Waxwings probably are the descendants of a migratory
population that diverged from the primitive population at an early
time in the history of the family. Owing to their adaptations to
survive in the north, waxwings no longer return south in the autumn.
Palm-chats (subfamily Dulinae) are descendants of an isolated
population of the family stock that developed communal living habits
as one specialization. Silky Flycatchers (subfamily Ptilogonatinae)
became modified to catch insects, and have specializations that
roughly parallel those of the Tyrannid flycatchers.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account