Physician and patient : $b or, a practical view of the mutual duties, relations and interests of the medical profession and the communityHooker, Worthington
Science
Physician and patient : $b or, a practical view of the mutual duties, relations and interests of the medical profession and the community
Hooker, Worthington
Medical ethics; Physician and patient; Physicians; Quacks and quackery
Such views as these, being prevalent among Thompsonians, both in
regard to education and to the administration of medicine, it is not
strange that Thompsonian practitioners should be a very ignorant
set of men. In the remarks, which their special hatred for mineral
medicines, leads them to make, they sometimes confound mineral and
vegetable substances together. A Thompsonian of some considerable
note, finding that a patient was applying hot camphor cloths to her
side to relieve pain, said with an air of authority, ‘away with your
camphor—none of your _minerals_ where I am.’—‘What _shall_ we put
on doctor?’ asked a by-stander. ‘A hot bag of salt,’ said he. What
_vegetable_ mine the salt came from I did not learn. So too, a
Thompsonian lecturer told his hearers, that he disapproved of _all_
mineral medicines, such as mercury, _opium_, arsenic, &c.
We occasionally hear some singular reasoning from Thompsonians
in regard to the _modus operandi_ of medicines. Though this is
confessedly a very difficult subject, they claim to know all about
it, and give their opinions in regard to it without any hesitation.
A patient once told me that, among the many physicians of whom she
had suffered many things was a Thompsonian of considerable celebrity.
He assured her that he could effect a cure in a very short time. He
began his treatment with the process of steaming. Some heated bricks
wrapped in wet flannel were placed around her in bed. Presently some
one asked ‘what is it that smells so?’—‘O’ said the doctor, ‘it is
the smell of the disease coming out through the pores—things are
working nicely—this is just as I want to have it. Disease very often
comes out in this way, through the pores, and sometimes I have known
the smell to be so strong, that you could hardly stay in the room.’
As he went on to give his clinical lecture on ‘disease coming out
through the pores,’ the smell grew worse and worse, as if to give
emphasis to his remarks. But at length some one suggested that it
was a little like the smell of burnt flannel, and on examination,
it was found that one of the bricks had scorched the flannel which
was around it. She at once told the doctor, that she had no farther
use for his services, for if he did not know enough to distinguish
between the smell of ‘disease coming out through the pores,’ and the
smell of burnt flannel, he did not know enough to doctor her.
This system of quackery has obtained a large share of its popularity,
by the appeal which it has made to two forms of popular sentiment,
which have been for some time peculiarly prevalent. I refer to the
sentiment of _radicalism_, and to the prejudice against _mineral_
medicines.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account