Plutarch's essays and miscellanies, Vol. 3 (of 5) : $b Comprising all his works collected under the title of "Morals"Plutarch
Philosophy
Plutarch's essays and miscellanies, Vol. 3 (of 5) : $b Comprising all his works collected under the title of "Morals"
Plutarch
Classical literature; Essays; Ethics; Philosophy
4. And when I put in my advice, saying that it was as seasonable to
discourse of thunder and lightning amidst our cups as it would be in a
comedy to bring in engines to throw out lightning, the company agreed
to set aside all other questions relating to the subject, and desired
me only to proceed on this head, Why are men asleep never blasted
with lightning? And I, though I knew I should get no great credit by
proposing a cause whose reason was common to other things, said thus:
Lightning is wonderfully piercing and subtile, partly because it rises
from a very pure substance, and partly because by the swiftness of its
motion it purges itself and throws off all gross earthy particles that
are mixed with it. Nothing, says Democritus, is blasted with lightning,
that cannot resist and stop the motion of the pure flame. Thus the
close bodies, as brass, silver, and the like, which stop it, feel its
force and are melted, because they resist; whilst rare, thin bodies,
and such as are full of pores, are passed through and not hurted, as
clothes or dry wood. It blasts green wood or grass, the moisture within
them being seized and kindled by the flame. Now, if it is true that men
asleep are never killed by lightning, from what we have proposed, and
not from any thing else, we must endeavor to draw the cause. Now the
bodies of those that are awake are stiffer and more apt to resist, all
the parts being full of spirits; which as it were in a harp, distending
and screwing up the organs of sense, makes the body of the animal
firm, close, and compacted. But when men are asleep, the organs are
let down, and the body becomes rare, lax, and loose; and the spirits
failing, it hath abundance of pores, through which small sounds and
smells do flow insensibly. For in that case, there is nothing that can
resist, and by this resistance receive any sensible impression from
any objects that are presented, much less from such as are so subtile
and move so swiftly as lightning. Things that are weak Nature shields
from harm, fencing them about with some hard thick covering; but those
things that cannot be resisted do less harm to the bodies that yield
than to those that oppose their force. Besides, those that are asleep
are not startled at the thunder; they have no consternation upon them,
which kills a great many that are no otherwise hurt, and we know that
thousands die with the very fear of being killed. Even shepherds teach
their sheep to run together into a flock when it thunders, for whilst
they lie scattered they die with fear; and we see thousands fall, which
have no marks of any stroke or fire about them, their souls (as it
seems), like birds, flying out of their bodies at the fright. For many,
as Euripides says,
A clap hath killed, yet ne’er drew drop of blood.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account