Plutarch's essays and miscellanies, Vol. 3 (of 5) : $b Comprising all his works collected under the title of "Morals"Plutarch
Philosophy
Plutarch's essays and miscellanies, Vol. 3 (of 5) : $b Comprising all his works collected under the title of "Morals"
Plutarch
Classical literature; Essays; Ethics; Philosophy
1. Some at the table were of opinion that Achilles talked nonsense when
he bade Patroclus “mix the wine stronger,” subjoining this reason,
For now I entertain my dearest friends.
But Niceratus a Macedonian, my particular acquaintance, maintained
that ζωρόν did not signify pure but hot wine; as if it were derived
from ζωτικός and ζέσις (_life-giving_ and _boiling_), and
it were requisite at the coming of his friends to temper a fresh
bowl, as every one of us in his offering at the altar pours out fresh
wine. But Socicles the poet, remembering a saying of Empedocles,
that in the great universal change those things which before were
ἄκρατα, _unmixed_, should then be ζωρά, affirmed that ζωρόν there
signified εὔκρατον, _well tempered_, and that Achilles might with
a great deal of reason bid Patroclus provide well-tempered wine for the
entertainment of his friends; and it was not absurd (he said) to use
ζωρότερον for ζωρόν, any more than δεξιτερόν for δεξιόν, or θηλύτερον
for θῆλυ, for the comparatives are very properly put for the positives.
My friend Antipater said that years were anciently called ὧροι, and
that the particle ζα in composition signified greatness; and therefore
old wine, that had been kept for many years, was called by Achilles
ζωρόν.
2. I put them in mind that some imagine that θερμόν, _hot_, is
signified by ζωρότερον, and that hotter means simply faster, as when we
command servants to bestir themselves more hotly or in hotter haste.
But I must confess, your dispute is frivolous, since it is raised upon
this supposition, that if ζωρότερον signifies _more pure wine_,
Achilles’s command would be absurd, as Zoilus of Amphipolis imagined.
For first he did not consider that Achilles saw Phoenix and Ulysses
to be old men, who are not pleased with diluted wine, and upon that
account forbade any mixture. Besides, having been Chiron’s scholar, and
from him having learned the rules of diet, he considered that weaker
and more diluted liquors were fittest for those bodies that lay at
ease, and were not employed in their customary exercise or labor. Thus
with the other provender he gave his horses smallage, and this upon
very good reason; for horses that lie still grow sore in their feet,
and smallage is the best remedy in the world against that. And you will
not find smallage or any thing of the same nature given to any other
horses in the whole Iliad. Thus Achilles, being skilled in physic,
provided suitable provender for his horses, and used the lightest diet
himself, as the fittest whilst he lay at ease. But those that had been
wearied all day in fight he did not think convenient to treat like
those that had lain at ease, but commanded more pure and stronger wine
to be prepared. Besides, Achilles doth not appear to be naturally
addicted to drinking, but he was of a haughty inexorable temper.
No pleasant humor, no soft mind he bore,
But was all fire and rage.[85]
And in another place very plainly Homer says, that
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account