Poine: a study in ancient Greek blood-vengeanceTreston, Hubert Joseph
History
Poine: a study in ancient Greek blood-vengeance
Treston, Hubert Joseph
Criminal law (Greek law); Greece -- Civilization; Greek drama (Tragedy) -- History and criticism; Homicide (Greek law); Vendetta
Coulanges[81] implies that in addition to clan-religion there was
domestic worship. Now this domestic worship was shared by a husband and
wife who normally belonged to two different clans, and are we to assume
that if a husband slew his wife or a wife her husband, the domestic
religion would have compelled them to go into exile even when the clan
could atone by wergeld? This point we cannot decide with any certainty.
Clytaemnestra, in later legend, offers sacrifice at the tomb of her
murdered husband: her children assert, not that it is sacrilegious, but
only that it is unavailing as a placation. We think that the tribal penal
code did not demand the exile penalty for homicide of this kind and would
have permitted wergeld. But within the genuine kindred, and especially
within the small kindred, bloodshed, particularly parricide, was from the
earliest times a serious religious offence.
There remain for discussion two problems which most writers regard as
intimately related—namely, the origin and evolution of the Erinnyes, and
the source and significance of the ritual of homicide-purgation.
THE ERINNYES AND PURGATION
The Greek word ἐριννύς is probably an adjective meaning ‘angry,’ and
should therefore be applicable to any spirit, whether ghost or god. But
Miss Harrison[82] believes that the word was originally an epithet of a
ghost or _ker_. The following is a summary of her opinions: The _Keres_
(κῆρες), she thinks, were primarily ghosts: they were neutral potencies
who might be either quite harmless[83] or baleful bacilli, or good
spirits.[84] The _word_ Erinnys was originally probably an epithet of
_ker_, and denoted a ghost-pest, a Poine. The Erinnys primarily is the
_ker_ of a human being unrighteously slain. It is the _ker_ as Poine.[85]
Thus, because it was a _ker_, the Erinnys was primarily a human ghost,
but the word came, by a process of specialisation, to be applied only
to such ghosts as are angry because they have been murdered.[86] In
Homer, she thinks, the Erinnyes have passed beyond this stage and are
‘personified (? deified) almost beyond recognition.’ They are no longer
souls, but the avengers of souls. They have even lost their exclusive
connexion with souls, and are become the avengers of the moral law, vague
equivalents of underworld Zeus and Persephone.[87]
Now Miss Harrison implicitly connects the Erinnyes with purgation, since
she asserts that ‘purification (_i.e._ purgation) is the placation of
ghosts.’[88] But in Homeric times the ghosts of murdered men would
not, she holds, accept any purgation sacrifice save the blood of the
murderer.[89] Therefore, in a certain sense homicide could be purged, and
in another sense it could not be purged in Homeric times!
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account