Popular lectures on scientific subjects : $b Second series, with an autobiography of the authorHelmholtz, Hermann von
Science
Popular lectures on scientific subjects : $b Second series, with an autobiography of the author
Helmholtz, Hermann von
Science; Universities and colleges -- Germany
A professor of physiology of that time, celebrated for his literary
activity, and noted as an orator and intelligent man, had a dispute
on the images in the eye with his colleague the physicist. The latter
challenged the physiologist to visit him and witness the experiment.
The physiologist, however, refused his request with indignation;
alleging that a physiologist had nothing to do with experiments;
they were of no good but for the physicist. Another aged and learned
professor of therapeutics, who occupied himself much with the
reorganisation of the Universities, was urgent with me to divide
physiology, in order to restore the good old time; that I myself
should lecture on the really intellectual part, and should hand over
the lower experimental part to a colleague whom he regarded as good
enough for the purpose. He quite gave me up when I said that I myself
considered experiments to be the true basis of science.
I mention these points, which I myself have experienced, to elucidate
the feeling of the older schools, and indeed of the most illustrious
representatives of medical science, in reference to the progressive set
of ideas of the natural sciences; in literature these ideas naturally
found feebler expression, for the old gentlemen were cautious and
worldly wise.
You will understand how great a hindrance to progress such a feeling on
the part of influential and respected men must have been. The medical
education of that time was based mainly on the study of books; there
were still lectures, which were restricted to mere dictation; for
experiments and demonstrations in the laboratory the provision made was
sometimes good and sometimes the reverse; there were no physiological
and physical laboratories in which the student himself might go to
work. Liebig’s great deed, the foundation of the chemical laboratory,
was complete, as far as chemistry was concerned, but his example had
not been imitated elsewhere. Yet medicine possessed in anatomical
dissections a great means of education for independent observation,
which is wanting in the other faculties, and to which I am disposed
to attach great weight. Microscopic demonstrations were isolated
and infrequent in the lectures. Microscopic instruments were costly
and scarce. I came into possession of one by having spent my autumn
vacation in 1841 in the Charité, prostrated by typhoid fever; as pupil,
I was nursed without expense, and on my recovery I found myself in
possession of the savings of my small resources. The instrument was not
beautiful, yet I was able to recognise by its means the prolongations
of the ganglionic cells in the invertebrata, which I described in
my dissertation, and to investigate the vibrions in my research on
putrefaction and fermentation.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account