Popular lectures on scientific subjects : $b Second series, with an autobiography of the authorHelmholtz, Hermann von
Science
Popular lectures on scientific subjects : $b Second series, with an autobiography of the author
Helmholtz, Hermann von
Science; Universities and colleges -- Germany
The development of French Universities has been quite different, and
indeed almost in the opposite direction. In accordance with the
tendency of the French to throw overboard everything of historic
development to suit some rationalistic theory, their faculties have
logically become purely institutes for instruction--special schools,
with definite regulations for the course of instruction, developed
and quite distinct from those institutions which are to further the
progress of science, such as the _Collège de France_, the _Jardin des
Plantes_, and the _École des Études Supérieures_. The faculties are
entirely separated from one another, even when they are in the same
town. The course of study is definitely prescribed, and is controlled
by frequent examinations. French teaching is confined to that which
is clearly established, and transmits this in a well-arranged, well
worked-out manner, which is easily intelligible, and does not excite
doubt nor the necessity for deeper inquiry. The teachers need only
possess good receptive talents. Thus in France it is looked upon as a
false step when a young man of promising talent takes a professorship
in a faculty in the provinces. The method of instruction in France is
well adapted to give pupils, of even moderate capacity, sufficient
knowledge for the routine of their calling. They have no choice between
different teachers, and they swear _in verba magistri_; this gives a
happy self-satisfaction and freedom from doubts. If the teacher has
been well chosen, this is sufficient in ordinary cases, in which the
pupil does what he has seen his teacher do. It is only unusual cases
that test how much actual insight and judgment the pupil has acquired.
The French people are moreover gifted, vivacious, and ambitious, and
this corrects many defects in their system of teaching.
A special feature in the organisation of French Universities
consists in the fact that the position of the teacher is quite
independent of the favour of his hearers; the pupils who belong to
his faculty are generally compelled to attend his lectures, and the
far from inconsiderable fees which they pay flow into the chest of
the Minister of Education; the regular salaries of the University
professors are defrayed from this source; the State gives but an
insignificant contribution towards the maintenance of the University.
When, therefore, the teacher has no real pleasure in teaching, or
is not ambitious of having a number of pupils, he very soon becomes
indifferent to the success of his teaching, and is inclined to take
things easily.
Outside the lecture-rooms, the French students live without control,
and associate with young men of other callings, without any special
_esprit de corps_ or common feeling.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account