Popular lectures on scientific subjects : $b Second series, with an autobiography of the authorHelmholtz, Hermann von
Science
Popular lectures on scientific subjects : $b Second series, with an autobiography of the author
Helmholtz, Hermann von
Science; Universities and colleges -- Germany
When I think of my own student life, and of the impression which a man
like Johannes Müller, the physiologist, made upon us, I must place a
very high value upon this latter point. Anyone who has once come in
contact with one or more men of the first rank must have had his whole
mental standard altered for the rest of his life. Such intercourse is,
moreover, the most interesting that life can offer.
You, my younger friends, have received in this freedom of the German
students a costly and valuable inheritance of preceding generations.
Keep it--and hand it on to coming races, purified and ennobled if
possible. You have to maintain it, by each, in his place, taking care
that the body of German students is worthy of the confidence which has
hitherto accorded such a measure of freedom. But freedom necessarily
implies responsibility. It is as injurious a present for weak, as it is
valuable for strong characters. Do not wonder if parents and statesmen
sometimes urge that a more rigid system of supervision and control,
like that of the English, shall be introduced even among us. There
is no doubt that, by such a system, many a one would be saved who is
ruined by freedom. But the State and the Nation is best served by those
who can bear freedom, and have shown that they know how to work and to
struggle, from their own force and insight and from their own interest
in science.
My having previously dwelt on the influence of mental intercourse with
distinguished men, leads me to discuss another point in which German
Universities are distinguished from the English and French ones. It is
that we start with the object of having instruction given, if possible,
only by teachers who have proved their own power of advancing science.
This also is a point in respect to which the English and French often
express their surprise. They lay more weight than the Germans on what
is called the ‘talent for teaching’--that is, the power of explaining
the subjects of instruction in a well-arranged and clear manner, and,
if possible, with eloquence, and so as to entertain and to fix the
attention. Lectures of eloquent orators at the Collège de France,
Jardin des Plantes, as well as in Oxford and Cambridge, are often the
centres of the elegant and the educated world. In Germany we are not
only indifferent to, but even distrustful of, oratorical ornament,
and often enough are more negligent than we should be of the outer
forms of the lecture. There can be no doubt that a good lecture can
be followed with far less exertion than a bad one; that the matter
of the first can be more certainly and completely apprehended; that
a well-arranged explanation, which develops the salient points and
the divisions of the subject, and which brings it, as it were, almost
intuitively before us, can impart more information in the same time
than one which has the opposite qualities. I am by no means prepared
to defend what is, frequently, our too great contempt for form in
speech and in writing.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account