Popular lectures on scientific subjects : $b Second series, with an autobiography of the authorHelmholtz, Hermann von
Science
Popular lectures on scientific subjects : $b Second series, with an autobiography of the author
Helmholtz, Hermann von
Science; Universities and colleges -- Germany
We see best how strenuously the Universities under this system have
sought to attract the scientific ability of Germany when we consider
how many pioneers have remained outside the Universities. The answer
to such an inquiry is given in the not infrequent jest or sneer that
all wisdom in Germany is professorial wisdom. If we look at England,
we see men like Humphry Davy, Faraday, Mill, Grote, who have had
no connection with English Universities. If, on the other hand, we
deduct from the list of German men of science those who, like David
Strauss, have been driven away by Government for ecclesiastical or for
political reasons, and those who, as members of learned Academies, had
the right to deliver lectures in the Universities, as Alexander and
Wilhelm von Humboldt, Leopold von Buch, and others, the rest will only
form a small fraction of the number of the men of equal scientific
standing who have been at work in the Universities; while the same
calculation made for England would give exactly the opposite result.
I have often wondered that the Royal Institution of London, a private
Society, which provides for its members and others short courses of
lectures on the Progress of Natural Science, should have been able to
retain permanently the services of men of such scientific importance as
Humphry Davy and Faraday. It was no question of great emoluments; these
men were manifestly attracted by a select public consisting of men and
women of independent mental culture. In Germany the Universities are
unmistakably the institutions which exert the most powerful attraction
on the taught. But it is clear that this attraction depends on the
teacher’s hope that he will not only find in the University a body of
pupils enthusiastic and accustomed to work, but such also as devote
themselves to the formation of an independent conviction. It is only
with such students that the intelligence of the teacher bears any
further fruit.
The entire organisation of our Universities is thus permeated by
this respect for a free independent conviction, which is more
strongly impressed on the Germans than on their Aryan kindred of the
Celtic and Romanic branches, in whom practical political motives
have greater weight. They are able, and as it would seem with
perfect conscientiousness, to restrain the inquiring mind from the
investigation of those principles which appear to them to be beyond
the range of discussion, as forming the foundation of their political,
social, and religious organisation; they think themselves quite
justified in not allowing their youth to look beyond the boundary which
they themselves are not disposed to overstep.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account