Popular lectures on scientific subjects : $b Second series, with an autobiography of the authorHelmholtz, Hermann von
Science
Popular lectures on scientific subjects : $b Second series, with an autobiography of the author
Helmholtz, Hermann von
Science; Universities and colleges -- Germany
If, therefore, any region of questions is to be considered as outside
the range of discussion, however remote and restricted it may be, and
however good may be the intention, the pupils must be kept in the
prescribed path, and teachers must be appointed who do not rebel
against authority. We can then, however, only speak of free conviction
in a very limited sense.
You see how different was the plan of our forefathers. However
violently they may at times have interfered with individual results of
scientific inquiry, they never wished to pull it up by the roots. An
opinion which was not based upon independent conviction appeared to
them of no value. In their hearts they never lost faith that freedom
alone could cure the errors of freedom, and a riper knowledge the
errors of what is unripe. The same spirit which overthrew the yoke of
the Church of Rome, also organised the German Universities.
But any institution based upon freedom must also be able to calculate
on the judgment and reasonableness of those to whom freedom is granted.
Apart from the points which have been previously discussed, where
the students themselves are left to decide on the course of their
studies and to select their teachers, the above considerations show
how the students react upon their teachers. To produce a good course
of lectures is a labour which is renewed every term. New matter is
continually being added which necessitates a reconsideration and a
rearrangement of the old from fresh points of view. The teacher would
soon be dispirited in his work if he could not count upon the zeal
and the interest of his hearers. The estimate which he places on his
task will depend on how far he is followed by the appreciation of a
sufficient number of, at any rate, his more intelligent hearers. The
influx of hearers to the lectures of a teacher has no slight influence
upon his fame and promotion, and, therefore, upon the composition of
the body of teachers. In all these respects, it is assumed that the
general public opinion among the students cannot go permanently wrong.
The majority of them--who are, as it were, the representatives of the
general opinion--must come to us with a sufficiently logically trained
judgment, with a sufficient habit of mental exertion, with a tact
sufficiently developed on the best models, to be able to discriminate
truth from the babbling appearance of truth. Among the students are
to be found those intelligent heads who will be the mental leaders of
the next generation, and who, perhaps, in a few years, will direct to
themselves the eyes of the world. Occasional errors in youthful and
excitable spirits naturally occur; but, on the whole, we may be pretty
sure that they will soon set themselves right.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account