Popular misgovernment in the United StatesCruikshank, Alfred Byron
History
Popular misgovernment in the United States
Cruikshank, Alfred Byron
Suffrage -- United States; United States -- Politics and government
“There was at one period an enthusiastic belief that in the
Constitution of the United States reflection and choice had at last
superseded accident and force, and that a model of free government
was now provided by which all countries and peoples might benefit.
The effect upon governmental arrangements was once very marked, but
complete examination of the documents shows that this influence
soon spent itself, and a decided change of disposition took place.
If, for instance, one shall attentively consider the constitutional
documents of all the Americas, one will observe, that although in
their early forms the Constitution of the United States was the
model, this is no longer the case. The Constitution of the French
republic now excels it in influence. The United States has lost its
lead, despite the fact that never has our country bulked larger in
the world than now. The present situation is indeed a striking
confirmation of Hamilton’s opinion that error in our republic
becomes the general misfortune of mankind, for it is a fact well
known to every student of politics that a belief that our system of
government is a failure on the essential point of justice is now a
potent influence on the side of social revolution throughout the
world....
Students of political science will generally agree that the three
greatest works of this class, all displaying wide knowledge and
deep thought, are De Tocqueville’s _Democracy in America_, first
published in 1885; Bryce’s _American Commonwealth_, 1888; and
Ostrogorski’s _Democracy and the Organization of Political
Parties_, 1902. These works form a crescendo of censure upon
American government, each re-examination of the subject confirming
previous disapproval and adding to it.”
Needless to say that the writers referred to by Ford and others
hereinafter referred to fully sustain his statements above quoted. Our
government has not only been a failure on the essential point of justice
as President Ford points out, but a still greater failure on the equally
essential points of purity and efficiency. The democratic system in
actual operation among us has been productive of corruption and
mismanagement to such an extent as to cause and justify the almost
universal verdict that popular misgovernment rather than popular
government has been the outcome. Hence general dissatisfaction and
unrest; hence the danger of revolutionary movements, with which we are
openly threatened.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account