Prejudices, fifth seriesMencken, H. L. (Henry Louis)
History
Prejudices, fifth series
Mencken, H. L. (Henry Louis)
American essays -- 20th century; American literature -- History and criticism; Literature -- History and criticism
I do not denounce them because they write so badly; I merely record the
fact in a sad, scientific spirit. Even in such twilight regions of the
intellect the style remains the man. What is in the head infallibly
oozes out of the nub of the pen. If it is sparkling Burgundy the
writing is full of life and charm. If it is mush the writing is mush
too. The late Dr. Harding, twenty-ninth President of the Federal Union,
was a highly self-conscious stylist. He practiced prose composition
assiduously, and was regarded by the pedagogues of Marion, Ohio, and
vicinity as a very talented fellow. But when he sent a message to
Congress it was so muddled in style that even the late Henry Cabot
Lodge, a professional literary man, could not understand it. Why?
Simply because Dr. Harding’s thoughts, on the high and grave subjects
he discussed, were so muddled that he couldn’t understand them himself.
But on matters within his range of customary meditation he was clear
and even charming, as all of us are. I once heard him deliver a brief
address upon the ideals of the Elks. It was a topic close to his heart,
and he had thought about it at length and _con amore_. The result
was an excellent speech--clear, logical, forceful, and with a touch
of wild, romantic beauty. His sentences hung together. He employed
simple words, and put them together with skill. But when, at a public
meeting in Washington, he essayed to deliver an oration on the subject
of the late Dante Alighieri, he quickly became so obscure and absurd
that even the Diplomatic Corps began to snicker. The cause was plain:
he knew no more about Dante than a Tennessee county judge knows about
the Institutes of Justinian. Trying to formulate ideas upon the topic,
he could get together only a few disjected fragments and ghosts of
ideas--here an ear, there a section of tibia, beyond a puff of soul
substance or other gas. The resultant speech was thus enigmatical,
cacophonous and awful stuff. It sounded precisely like a lecture by a
college professor on style.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account