Premature Burial and How It May Be PreventedTebb, William
Science
Premature Burial and How It May Be Prevented
Tebb, William
Burial, Premature
It is regrettable that medical practitioners, neither in this nor in
any of the Continental states, except, possibly, a few in Germany,
have been trained to distinguish apparent from real death; and when
a case of death-trance occurs, they certify to actual death, and the
unfortunate person is interred in a strong coffin, which effectually
conceals the tragedy following resuscitation. Moreover, the ordinary
practitioner, both in England and the United States, considers himself
exonerated from blame when he thus follows the traditions and practice
of the heads of his profession. Personally, he has neither the time,
opportunity, or inclination to study the abnormal phenomena of trance,
catalepsy, or hypnotisation, and thus the evil of live sepulture is
perpetuated from generation to generation.
SUMMARY OF CONCLUSIONS.
(1) An examination of both the historical and modern cases of trance,
catalepsy, and other death-counterfeits shows that nothing is more
uncertain than the so-called signs of death, and that in all countries
and in all ages many persons supposed by their attendant physicians and
relations to be dead have revived, while the cases are as numerous and
the danger as great at the present day as at any previous period.
(2) That the risk of premature burial is especially serious in France,
in Spain and Portugal, in the west of Ireland, in both European and
Asiatic Turkey, and in India; also amongst the Jews, where both the
Jewish law and ancient customs enjoin burial within a few hours of
death, and for similar reasons in all Oriental countries; and in the
Southern States of North America.
(3) That the various signs which are supposed to indicate death, such
as the cessation of respiration and of cardiac action, a pale, waxy
and death-like appearance, the stiffening of the limbs, or _rigor
mortis_, insensibility to cutaneous excitation, the departure of heat
from the body, are singly and collectively illusory; the only safe and
infallible test of dissolution being the manifestation of putrefaction
in the abdomen.
(4) That medical death-certificates have been shown by various
witnesses before the Select Parliamentary Committee of Inquiry
of 1893-94 to be often misleading as to the cause of death, and
inconclusive as to the fact of death. Any compulsory extension of the
death-certification system in the present imperfect state of medical
knowledge would only partially meet the necessities of the case,
and might have the effect of crystallising a defective system into
perfunctory routine. A certain safeguard would, however, be provided
if the law made it binding on medical practitioners to set forth on
the death-certificate a precise statement of indications showing that
dissolution has actually occurred.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account