Ireland -- Politics and government -- 1901-1910; Land tenure -- Ireland
little changed.[191] Trinity College remains a Protestant institution
well endowed, almost a monopoly of the Protestant upper class in Ireland,
practically little resorted to by Irish Catholics; the Queen's Colleges
are avoided by the Irish Catholics, as being 'irreligious' if called
'non-religious,' though the College of Belfast suits Presbyterian views;
they, too, receive a large bounty from the State; but the Catholic
University, the true seminary for the upper middle Catholic classes, and
now divided into different colleges, is still, as such, left out in the
cold. Its students, no doubt, can obtain Royal University degrees, and
some of its professors have been placed as examiners on that foundation;
but it is the veriest mockery to call this justice when we look at Trinity
College and the Queen's Colleges. 'The words of scripture are reversed,'
in Macaulay's language; 'the rich are filled with good things and the
hungry are sent empty away.'
I do not envy those who, whatever their reasons, refuse to acknowledge the
wrong done by these arrangements. It will hardly be denied, in the
twentieth century, that Protestant ascendency ought not to exist in any
sphere of Irish affairs, and that in University life, as in all matters,
Irish Catholics ought to have civil equality, and that without a violation
of the rights of conscience. It has been triumphantly maintained that, in
high education, these conditions are actually fulfilled in Ireland;
Trinity College and the Queen's Colleges are accessible to all students,
without regard to their religion or no religion; these have a perfectly
equal right to share in the government and the honours of institutions
thrown completely open. But those who argue in this way either shut their
eyes to facts, or will not perceive that this fine 'liberalism' in Ireland
works sheer injustice. Catholics are but a handful of students in Trinity
College and the Queen's Colleges compared to what their natural proportion
ought to be; Trinity College, if nominally open, is in all essential
respects Protestant; the Queen's Colleges as being 'non-religious,' that
is, in the view of their Church 'irreligious,' are practically avoided by
Irish Catholics; yet the State endows Trinity College and the Queen's
Colleges; it starves the Catholic University and other Catholic colleges,
which are thus unfairly handicapped by their rivals. If this is not
furthering Protestant ascendency in Irish high education, and denying
civil equality to Irish Catholics who, in this matter, will not forego the
rights of conscience, I do not know what else it can be; it seems to me to
be iniquity in no doubtful sense. And are the objections of the Irish
Catholics, in this province, as 'irrational' and 'superstitious' as has
been scoffingly said? Reverse the case of Trinity College: suppose that
England was a Catholic Power, and that she kept up a great Catholic
University in the Irish capital, discountenancing Protestant institutions
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account