Ireland -- Politics and government -- 1901-1910; Land tenure -- Ireland
in many ways, how many Protestants would enter its walls, how soon would
the cry of Catholic ascendency be raised? Or suppose that Oxford and
Cambridge were made 'non-religious,' as the Queen's Colleges in Ireland
are, would not an immense majority of English parents declare that these
seats of learning were 'godless,' and persistently keep their sons away
from them? The simple truth is that the Catholic objections to Trinity
College and the Queen's Colleges are really those which, in this matter,
have been entertained by the deepest thinkers; to my mind, at least, they
seem perfectly well-founded. As to the statement that these objections are
those of the Irish Catholic bishops alone, and are mere 'superstitious
fancies,' it is enough to reply that, on two occasions, the Irish
Catholic laity have distinctly pronounced on this subject, and have
declared that they agree with the heads of their Church. And as to the
argument that Catholic States do not endow sectarian institutions like the
Catholic University and other Irish Catholic colleges, it will be quite
time enough to examine this when anything like such a state of things can
be found as that which at present exists in Ireland.
One argument, however, seldom frankly set forth, but hinted at in a
variety of ways, has been a real obstacle to a reform of this vicious
system; it strongly appeals to British national prejudice, of all
aberrations of opinion the most difficult to overcome. 'Popery,' it is
said, is a 'detestable thing;' a 'Protestant' State 'must have nothing to
do with it;' to endow a Catholic University in Ireland, therefore, or any
colleges of the same complexion, would be 'sacrificing to Baal,' or
something as wicked. Catholic Ireland must put up with Trinity College and
the Queen's Colleges, which have been made open to all sorts and
conditions of men; its 'conscientious objections' are mere 'bigotry.' This
reasoning, which condemns as impious the religion of the greatest part of
Christendom, would unfortunately overthrow many arrangements by which
provision has been made in our 'Protestant' State for Catholic
institutions of different kinds; if pushed to its consequences, it would
revive the penal code in Ireland, and lead to the confiscation of Catholic
charities. But though it has still indirectly an effect on some
politicians, it is, in its naked simplicity, only the faith of Mr. Kensit
and of those who walk in his footsteps; it is worthy of the philosophy of
Lord George Gordon, of the meekness of Orangeism, of the bray of Exeter
Hall. For some time a turn in British opinion has happily taken place;
'liberalism,' it has been perceived, in Irish University education has
failed; Mr. Arthur Balfour has made himself conspicuous in advocating the
just claims of Catholic Ireland. Even as I write a Commission is being
appointed to consider the whole subject of University life in Ireland;
there can be no reasonable doubt that it will fully bring to light the
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account