Presidential addresses and state papers, Volume 4 (of 7)Roosevelt, Theodore
History
Presidential addresses and state papers, Volume 4 (of 7)
Roosevelt, Theodore
Roosevelt, Theodore, 1858-1919; United States -- Politics and government -- 1901-1909
If your body objects to the passage of the proposed anti-injunction
bill, I have no question that you can stop it, for there is not a
capitalist concerned who simply as capitalist is not against it; though
I believe that a goodly number both of capitalists and wage-workers
who are concerned primarily as citizens favor it. The law was worked
over and substantially whipped into its present shape at a number of
conferences between representatives of the railroad organizations, of
the Department of Justice, and of the Bureau of Corporations with me.
It goes as far as I personally think it should go in limiting the right
of injunction; at any rate, no arguments have hitherto been advanced
which make me think it should go farther. I do not believe it has any
chance of passing, because there has been great criticism in both
Houses of Congress against the attitude of the Administration in going
so far as we have gone; and if you think it is not far enough, why,
you will have no earthly difficulty in killing the bill. Personally,
I think the proposed law a most admirable one, and I very sincerely
wish it would be put through. As for the right of injunction, it is
absolutely necessary to have this power lodged in the courts; though
of course any abuse of the power is strongly to be reprobated. During
the four and a half years that I have been President I do not remember
an instance where the Government has invoked the right of injunction
against a combination of laborers. We have invoked it certainly a score
of times against combinations of capital; I think possibly oftener.
Thus, though we have secured the issuance of injunctions in a number of
cases against capitalistic combinations, it has happened that we have
never tried to secure an injunction against a combination of labor.
But understand me, gentlemen; if I ever thought it necessary, if I
thought a combination of laborers were doing wrong, I would apply for
an injunction against them just as quick as against so many capitalists.
Now I come to the general subject of your petition. I wish in the
first place to state my regret that you did not divorce so much of
the petition as refers to the action of the Executive from so much
as refers to the action of the legislative branch, because I can not
consider any petition that you make that reflects upon the co-ordinate
branch of the Government, or that makes any charges whatever against
it. I would not even receive it save for the fact that in part it
affects the Executive. Therefore in what I have to say I shall limit
myself solely to what you assert in reference to the acts of the
Executive.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account