Primitive Athens as described by ThucydidesHarrison, Jane Ellen
History
Primitive Athens as described by Thucydides
Harrison, Jane Ellen
Athens (Greece) -- Antiquities; Athens (Greece) -- Description and travel
Finally, supposing for a moment that the passage of Thucydides leaves
us in doubt as to the site of the Enneakrounos, naturally our next step
would be to ask what does our next best authority, Pausanias, say?
Pausanias is a topographer by profession, surely we shall learn from him
where he saw the well-house. Pausanias[343] after seeing the statues of
Harmodios and Aristogeiton ‘not far from’ the temple of Ares, passes
straight on to a small group of monuments which he links together more
or less clearly; they are the Odeion; near to it the Enneakrounos;
above or beyond this the temples of Demeter and Kore; a little further
on the temple of Eukleia. It is quite true that he links the Odeion by
no connecting particle, but that is his frequent practice when passing
straight from one monument to another.
The uninstructed reader in his simplicity would naturally think that,
as Pausanias passes straight from the statues of the Tyrant Slayers
to the Odeion, the two lay somewhere not far apart, and so they did.
The Odeion in the days of Pausanias would almost certainly be near
the site of the ancient orchestra, where still are faint remains of
a semi-circular building (Fig. 46). Anyhow it stood close to the
Areopagos. But this is too simple and natural. Pausanias we are told,
here and nowhere else, abruptly breaks his narrative of the buildings
in the Kerameikos, and with no apparent reason and no hint in the text,
flies off for nearly half-a-mile and plants his reader on the banks
of the Ilissus,—a district, be it noted, that he later describes in
detail,—whence he shortly returns again without warning and finishes
his account of the Kerameikos. In a word we are presented with what is
known as the ‘Enneakrounos Episode.’ Various causes are suggested for the
‘Episode’; the leaves of the MS. got mixed, or Pausanias was staying with
friends near the Ilissus, and went home to lunch. The real cause of the
‘Episode’ is that Thucydides has been misunderstood, and that the late
compiler of the _Etymologicum Magnum_ has blundered. Pausanias[344] saw
the Odeion in the neighbourhood of the old orchestra at the south-west
of the Areopagos, the Enneakrounos near to it by the Pnyx rock, the
temples of Demeter and Kore ‘above it’ _on_ the Pnyx rock where were the
Thesmophorion[345] and the temple of Eukleia ‘not far off’; his course of
sight-seeing was here as elsewhere orderly and undisturbed.
* * * * *
Pausanias is seen to be at one with Thucydides and, thanks to Prof.
Dörpfeld, the evidence of both has been confirmed by excavation; the
sources of error and confusion in late authors, lexicographers and modern
archaeologists have come to light. Surely now at last the ‘Enneakrounos
Episode’ may be laid to sleep in peace.
FOOTNOTES
[1] Herod. VII. 140.
[2] Thucyd. II. 14 χαλεπῶς δὲ αὐτοῖς, διὰ τὸ ἀεὶ εἰωθέναι τοὺς πολλοὺς ἐν
τοῖς ἀγροῖς διαιτᾶσθαι, ἡ ἀνάστασις ἐγίγνετο.
[3] Thucyd. I. 5, 10.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account