Primitive Athens as described by ThucydidesHarrison, Jane Ellen
History
Primitive Athens as described by Thucydides
Harrison, Jane Ellen
Athens (Greece) -- Antiquities; Athens (Greece) -- Description and travel
Once embarked on the wrong hypothesis that Thucydides lays two
propositions before us, and that one of them is that the city lay to the
South, the downward road is easy. The four sanctuaries of Thucydides are
selected, it is supposed, to prove the second proposition, i.e. that the
city is to the South. Four sanctuaries lie ready, only too ready, to
hand. We have, South-East of the Acropolis (Fig. 49), a great Olympieion;
we know from Pausanias[293] that close by it was a great Pythion, within
the Olympieion was a precinct of Ge; and last and most convincing of all,
on the South-East slope of the Acropolis is the great Dionysiac theatre,
with its precinct and two temples. Truly a little archaeology is a
dangerous thing. So obvious, so striking are these identifications, that
at the first glance they seem to compel adhesion.
But a moment’s thought obliges us to see that, if tempting, these
identifications are impossible. From its _position_ the sanctuary
of Dionysos Eleuthereus might well have been one of those named by
Thucydides, because, as already noted (p. 67), while from his words
it would be impossible definitely to say whether the sanctuaries are
North, South, East, or West, assuredly the theatre and precinct of
Dionysos Eleuthereus _are_ ‘towards’ (πρὸς) the ancient city. But, as
we have already (p. 83) seen, it is from this familiar precinct, the
sanctuary of the later Dionysos Eleuthereus, that Thucydides is expressly
differentiating his more ancient precinct; the same is the case with the
Olympieion. Thucydides and everyone at Athens knew that this vast temple
was begun in the time of Peisistratos; was it likely to be chosen as
a sanctuary to show the limits (or even the direction) of the city of
Kekrops?
[Illustration: FIG. 49.]
As regards the Pythion, special stress has been laid on the fact
that it—not the sanctuary on the Long Rocks—is called by Pausanias
the Pythion; but the explanation is easy and manifest; Pausanias is
distinguishing it from the other sanctuary of Apollo near at hand, the
Delphinion[294].
Sanctuaries so late as these could not fairly be used to prove even
the _direction_ of the city of Kekrops; but, as already shown, it is
not direction, but _size_ with which Thucydides is concerned. To give
sanctuaries like the Olympieion and Pythion, which lay outside even
the city of Themistocles, as evidence of the smallness of an ancient
‘Mycenaean’ city, a Pelasgic fortress, is an absurdity so manifest that
statement is refutation. We are brought face to face with the third
source of error.
3. _The duplication of certain sanctuaries._
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account