Primitive Athens as described by ThucydidesHarrison, Jane Ellen
History
Primitive Athens as described by Thucydides
Harrison, Jane Ellen
Athens (Greece) -- Antiquities; Athens (Greece) -- Description and travel
The misinterpretation of Thucydides has been helped and indeed in a large
measure caused by a most curious historical fact, calculated until it was
properly understood to mislead anyone. _There was a duplication in two
different districts of certain of the most notable Athenian sanctuaries._
To the North and West of the Acropolis, as we have seen in detail, there
were sanctuaries of Zeus Olympios, of Apollo Pythios, of Ge and of
Dionysos, and near to them was a spring Kallirrhoë, and it is of these,
if our view be correct, that Thucydides makes mention, but none the less
the fact is patent to everyone who reads Pausanias and visits modern
Athens, that to the South-East of the Acropolis there are sanctuaries
of the same divinities, of Zeus Olympios, of Apollo Pythios, of Ge and
of Dionysos, and that near these also is a spring called to this day
Kallirrhoë. How did this come to be? What does it signify? The answer
once stated is simple and convincing. The duplication of sanctuaries is
due to a shift of population from North-West to South-East, from the
district of the Pnyx to the district of the Ilissus. This shift of
population is a fact historically attested.
* * * * *
Plutarch[295] in his treatise ‘On Banishment’ is trying to persuade us
that exile is in itself no hardship. He asks, ‘Are then those Athenians
to be accounted strangers and outlaws who moved from Melite to Diomeia,
whence they called the month Metageitnion, and the sacrifice they offered
took its name _Metageitnia_ from this removal, since they accepted
pleasantly and cheerfully their neighbourhood to new people? Surely
they are not.’ Plutarch’s argument does not come to much, but we are
grateful to him for recording the fact that there was this shift of
population, when or why, alas! we do not certainly know, from Melite in
the North-West to Diomeia in the South-East (Fig. 49). Did not the people
when they moved take with them their old place-names, their old local
legends, their Kallirrhoë? We have curious incidental evidence that they
did.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account