Private Sex Advice to Women: For Young Wives and those who Expect to be MarriedArmitage, Robert B.
Science
Private Sex Advice to Women: For Young Wives and those who Expect to be Married
Armitage, Robert B.
Marriage; Sex instruction; Women -- Health and hygiene
The objection to Birth Control on the ground that it would increase
illicit relations among men and women by means of removing the fear of
physical consequences, seems to many careful thinkers to be akin to the
old objection (now happily passing away) to the dissemination of the
knowledge of the treatment of venereal diseases, and to the public cure
of such diseases, on the ground that by so doing a part of the fear
concerning illicit relations was removed, and thereby illicit relations
actually encouraged. The result of this fallacious argument was the
enormous spread of venereal diseases, to the great hurt of the race; and
the encouragement of quacks and charlatans who fattened on the gains
received from the sufferers from this class of complaints. The argument
against Birth Control on similar grounds will be seen to be equally
fallacious, and capable of equally evil consequences, if the matter be
fairly and carefully considered.
Illicit relations, if prevented or regulated at all by society, must be
so regulated or prevented by other means than fear of conception. Such
fear, though it may deter for a short time, will usually be overcome in
time if the desire and temptation remain sufficiently strong. It is
doubtful whether any considerable number of women remain chaste for any
length of time simply by reason of fear of conception. If such fear be
the only remaining deterring factor, it will usually be swept away in
time under continued temptation, opportunity, and desire. Chastity and
virtue must have a far more solid foundation than such fear; and
experience repeatedly shows that such fear is but as shifting sand
sought to be employed as a foundation for the structure of chastity.
There is no reason whatsoever for believing that the scientific
knowledge of contraceptive methods, if generally possessed by married
people under the sanction of the law and society, would result in any
more cases of illicit relations than exist at the present time. It
might, it is true, result in less evil consequences of such relations in
some cases, as Dr. Robinson has so clearly pointed out in the above
quotation; but the relations in such cases would exist in either event.
Fear of conception, like fear of infection, has never, and will never
entirely prevent illicit relations between men and women; and to oppose
scientific information in the one case on these grounds, is as futile as
to oppose scientific treatment in the other case on the same grounds.
And when it is considered how society in general is injured by the
withholding of such information or treatment, respectively, the argument
in favor of such suppression of scientific truth and method is seen to
be actually dangerous to society and sub-service of the public good.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account