A study of the contoured map seems to me to be absolutely conclusive on
the question at issue, for it indicates clearly that at no time within
the geologically recent period can there have been any such continuous
channel as has been supposed. Let us try and trace, with the aid of the
map, the most likely course along which the ancient Libyan Nile-branch,
if ever one existed, must have flowed. Starting from the Nile in the
neighbourhood of Dongola, we observe that the lowest possible track is
through Sheb towards Kharga. But Sheb can only be reached after passing
over some 350 kilometres of desert lying well above the level of the
Nile at Dongola, which is about 230 metres above sea. It is, of course,
quite conceivable that even within geologically recent times the Nile at
Dongola may have been considerably above its present level; so that we
may pass over this first difficulty as not being definitely conclusive
against the hypothesis we are pursuing. From Sheb to the south end of
the Kharga depression there is a drop of about 160 metres, so that up to
this point a channel may have been possible. But from here onwards,
difficulties come in. If we turn northwards, we soon encounter the north
wall of Kharga, rising to 300 metres above sea-level; so there is no
continuing that way. Instead, we turn westwards towards Dakhla. But from
Kharga we have to pass over ground reaching very nearly to the 200-metre
contour for some 80 kilometres to enter the Dakhla depression, where we
drop to a level of 119 metres. We have to traverse some 15 kilometres at
altitudes above 200 metres to reach Abu Mungar, where the level is 117
metres; then a further 12 kilometres lying above the 200-metre contour
to get to Farafra, where the level descends to about 90 metres. To get
out of Farafra, we have again to traverse country lying over 200 metres
above sea, whether we choose a north-westerly route _viâ_ Sittra to the
Qattara depression, or a north-westerly one _viâ_ Baharia to the Wadi
Rayan and the Faiyum. Taking the first of these alternatives as being
the shorter, we cross some 30 kilometres of ground above the 200-metre
level, and a further 120 kilometres lying between the 200- and 100-metre
contours, before reaching the Qattara depression. And once we are in the
Qattara depression (the lowest point of which is 134 metres below sea),
there is no possibility of reaching the Mediterranean except by crossing
a considerable tract where the ground-level is over 100 metres above
sea-level.
A section of the route described, with a comparison-line passing through
the present Nile-levels in corresponding latitudes, is shown in the
figure below:
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account