Finally, in fig. 80, a design from a black-figured amphora[766], we
have the type most frequent of all; Hermes leads the three goddesses,
but in the Judgment of Paris _no figure of Paris is present_. Without
exaggeration it may be said that in three out of four representations of
the ‘Judgment’ in black-figured vase-paintings the protagonist is absent.
The scene takes the form of a simple procession, Hermes leading the three
goddesses.
This curious fact has escaped the attention of no archaeologist who
has examined the art types of the ‘Judgment.’ It has been variously
explained. At a time when vase-paintings were supposed to have had
literary sources, it was usual to attempt a literary explanation.
Attention was called to the fact that Proklos[767], in his excerpts
of the _Kypria_, noted that the goddesses, ‘by command of Zeus were
led to Ida by Hermes’; of this leading it was then supposed that the
vase-paintings were ‘illustrations.’ Such methods of interpretation are
now discredited; no one supposes that the illiterate vase-painter worked
with the text of the _Kypria_ before him. Art had its own traditions.
[Illustration: FIG. 80.]
Another explanation, scarcely more happy, has been attempted. ‘Archaic
art,’ we are told, ‘loved processions.’ Archaic art, concerned to fill
the space of a circular frieze surrounding a vase, did indeed ‘love
processions,’ but not with a passion so fond and unreasonable, and it
loved something else better, the lucid telling of a story. In depicting
other myths, archaic art is not driven to express a story in the terms of
an inappropriate procession; it is indeed largely governed by traditional
form, but not to the extent of tolerating needless obscurity. The
‘Judgment’ is a situation essentially stationary, with Paris for centre;
Hermes is subordinate.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account