Public health and insurance: American addressesNewsholme, Arthur, Sir
History
Public health and insurance: American addresses
Newsholme, Arthur, Sir
Health insurance -- Great Britain; Public health; Public health -- Great Britain
The separation of the medical work of Education Authorities from
public health medical work was contrary to the first principles
of sound administration; although it is possible that, owing to
the inertia in some public health circles, this separation at
first favored rapid advance in school hygiene; just as the early
development of public health apart from poor-law administration was
probably more rapid than could have been expected from centrally
ridden local authorities, concerned chiefly in keeping down the poor
rates.
_The Ad Hoc Vice_
But in both instances there was an offence against the first
principles of good administration, which require that when a special
function is to be undertaken it shall be undertaken by one governing
body for the whole community needing the service, and not for
different sections of the community by several governing bodies.
Medical treatment is needed for school children and for the poor
generally. Why separate this into two administrations? Hospitals are
required for paupers with tuberculosis, and for non-paupers with
tuberculosis. Why have two authorities for this work? The separate
existence of Education and Poor-Law Authorities _qûa_ medical
attendance on those children needing it erred, not only in this
fundamental respect, but also because neither of these authorities
had the preventive facilities and powers possessed by Public Health
Authorities, who were also partially engaged in the treatment of
disease.
The inveterate tendency in the past has been to create a new
authority when any new work was inaugurated, this authority then
fulfilling all purposes for a special portion of the community
and thus necessarily duplicating the staffs of other departments
of local or central government. The crowning instance of this
recurring instance of legislative myopia is seen in the case of the
National Insurance Act, under which has been provided an imperfect
and unsatisfactory domiciliary medical service for one-third of
the entire population of Great Britain, when by combining and
extending the medical forces of existing departments of the state, a
satisfactory service for all needing it would have been secured. The
axiom that “the object of community service is to do away with group
competitions and bring in its place group coöperation or team work”
(Goodnow), is especially applicable to all public health and medical
work; and the spirit of this axiom is infringed by the existence of
separate, sometimes competing, occasionally conflicting, services
under separate local and central control.
_Principles of Local Government_
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account