Rambles and Studies in GreeceMahaffy, J. P. (John Pentland)
History
Rambles and Studies in Greece
Mahaffy, J. P. (John Pentland)
Art, Greek; Greece -- Description and travel
39 The illustrated work of Michaelis is probably the most complete and
critical account both of the plan and the details, which have often
been discussed, and especially with great accuracy by Mr. Penrose,
whose monumental work, the _Principles of Athenian Architecture_,
has recently been republished. Among the many newer works, I would
call special attention to the first volume of Viollet-le-duc’s
_Entretiens sur l’Architecture_, already translated into English,
which is full of most instructing and suggestive observations on
Greek architecture; also to M. E. Bournouf’s _Acropole d’Athènes_.
40 They will be most readily consulted in the plates of Michaelis’s
_Parthenon_.
41 The discovery of the figures from the western pediment of the temple
at Olympia, carved by Alcamenes, a contemporary of Phidias, will
hardly lead us to modify this judgment. For though they show a great
talent in the composition, the defects in execution are so grave as
to lead many critics to suspect that we have in them the work of
mere local artists, certainly not the masterful hands that adorned
the Parthenon.
42 It is very uncertain, perhaps unlikely, that any of the
architectural sculpture we possess was actually finished by
Phidias’s own hand. But there can be no doubt that he directed it,
and must have designed much of it in detail, since the general
composition was certainly his creation.
43 This very pattern, in mahogany, with cane seats, and adapted, like
all Greek chairs, for loose cushions, was often used in eighteenth
century work, and may still be found in old Irish mansions furnished
at that epoch.
44 I state this because many critics have drawn an opposite inference
from a mistranslation of a passage in Plato (_Apol._ 26, E).
45 The exact number, according to Papadakis (cf. A. Müller,
_Bühnenalt._, p. 47), is stated at 27,500. But I am convinced this
is a great exaggeration. I should rather give 15,000 as a liberal
estimate; and this agrees with the measurements made for me by Dr.
Dörpfeld in 1889. This mistake is also due to misunderstanding a
passage in Plato’s _Symposium_, which says that “Agathon, whom
30,000 citizens hear——”. It is not said that they heard him at the
same time.
46 Cf. on this point my _History of Greek Literature_, i. p. 345.
47 Cf. on the details of Greek painting the last chapter of my _Social
Life in Greece_.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account