Reasons for Leaving the Church of RomeNolan, Laurence J.
Religion
Reasons for Leaving the Church of Rome
Nolan, Laurence J.
Anglican converts; Catholic Church -- Controversial literature -- Protestant authors; Catholic Church -- Ireland -- Clergy
But you, Roman Catholics, will assert, as an objection to what I have now
laid down, that as the senses deceived us in some respects they may for a
similar reason deceive us with regard to Transubstantiation: and in proof
of your assertion you will say (as others have said already) “that the
senses were deceived with regard to the Holy Ghost descending in the form
of a dove upon our Saviour receiving baptism from John;” and again you
will say, “that the senses have been deceived, inasmuch as they often
imagined angels to be men;” and therefore you will conclude, (as many
other Roman Catholics have done) that our senses are also deceived with
regard to Transubstantiation.
But, my friends, in the above instances the senses did not deceive,
inasmuch as the sense of vision or of sight, judges only from
appearances, and therefore its testimony in the cases quoted was true.
But who would assert that all the senses combined together in the above
instances were deceived; for, if all the senses were deceived, how could
reason pronounce upon the Holy Ghost being in the form of a dove, or the
angels being in the appearance of men, since it was from the senses only
that reason formed its judgment upon those occasions? And hence it is,
that while in certain cases, one portion of the senses imparts the
language of appearances, in the very same cases, another portion of our
senses implies the language of reality. And thus it is, that when the
senses, in their unimpaired and natural state, view objects at a proper
distance and through a proper medium, and that reason pronounces on their
veracity, disbelief can be no longer attached to their allegation, and
therefore it is, that Transubstantiation must be false; for the bread is
a quite palpable and perceptible object to the senses. The sight tells
that it is not the body—the touch feels it is not the body—the taste is
convinced of its not being the body—and the hearing, from the result of
sound, joins in the assertion that it is not the body; while reason also
attests the impossibility of its being the body of Christ.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account