Reasons for Leaving the Church of RomeNolan, Laurence J.
Religion
Reasons for Leaving the Church of Rome
Nolan, Laurence J.
Anglican converts; Catholic Church -- Controversial literature -- Protestant authors; Catholic Church -- Ireland -- Clergy
senses and most repugnant to our reason.
Among the many reasons that influenced my disbelief as to the doctrine of
Transubstantiation, there is another which I have considered to be of no
trivial tendency on the subject. I could not conceive that a finite or
material substance could be in two or more places at the same instant of
time: that is, I could not imagine those years past, that the body of our
Saviour, which the resurrection has not deprived of its humanity, could
be wholly and substantially in my hands, and wholly and substantially
over many portions of the globe, at the same identical moment; for I
consider that finite substances, whether glorified or corruptible, must
be subject to finite laws and regulations.
I know there are some however who would say, “that according to the
principles of metaphysical or philosophical observations, that it could
not be proved, that it is impossible for one body to be in many places at
the same time.”
But, my friends, a primary truth or self evident principle is not to be
lost among the mysterious windings of metaphysical subtleties; and when
reason fully comprehends or clearly understands a subject, and pronounces
truth over the object of its comprehension, the mad ravings of an
unrestrained philosophy are not to be credited, when suggesting a mere
suspicion of falsehood. Oh, my friends, to say that the same body could
be wholly and substantially in my hands during the time of the mass, and
wholly and substantially in the hands of thousands of others at the same
identical moment, and to require a belief of such an assertion, would be
demanding a complete surrender of common sense—a prostration of the human
intellect—while it would be divesting man of that grand attribute, that
noble characteristic of his being—I mean reason, which is the pure gift
of God.
But Roman Catholics say, “we do not understand the meaning of the
Trinity; that is, we do not understand how three persons constitute one
God, and therefore say they, though we do not comprehend how the body of
Christ could be in many places at the same time, still we should
believe.”
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account