Reasons for Leaving the Church of RomeNolan, Laurence J.
Religion
Reasons for Leaving the Church of Rome
Nolan, Laurence J.
Anglican converts; Catholic Church -- Controversial literature -- Protestant authors; Catholic Church -- Ireland -- Clergy
But, my friends, more of you, Roman Catholics, say upon this subject,
“that as the body of our Saviour entered into the room where the Apostles
were assembled together, though the windows and doors were closed at the
time, that therefore the body of our Saviour was and can be in many
places at the same time.”—The answer to this is plain; for in order that
this objection would hold good on the present occasion, it would be
necessary to shew that when the body of our Saviour was in the room with
the Apostles, it was also in another or a thousand different places at
the same instant of time. Many natural reasons also could be given as to
how the body of our Saviour might have entered the room of the Apostles
without their perceiving him enter, or without supposing that his body
was in many places at the same time.
There are more Roman Catholics who, in endeavouring to explain the mode
by which our Saviour’s body might be present in many places at the same
time, assert, “that as our Saviour fed the multitude of the five thousand
with five loaves, without any increase as to the number of the loaves,
that therefore our Saviour’s body could, by a similar mode of reasoning,
be received by many at the same instant.” {30} But, my friends, in order
that this argument would hold good in the present instance, it would be
necessary that each of the multitude referred to would eat an entire loaf
wholly and substantially, without part or parcel; for Roman Catholics
hold, that it is not a part of our Saviour’s body, but the whole of his
body, which is taken by each individual, on receiving their sacrament.
Some Roman Catholics also endeavour to show our Saviour’s body could be
present in many places at the same time, “by attaching to it a velocity,
or what is the same, a quickness, which would be almost equal to an
infinite velocity or quickness; so that no sensible interval of time
would exist between a body being here and a thousand separate parts of
the globe at the same instant.” But this is totally subversive of the
doctrine of Transubstantiation; for, no matter how great the velocity or
quickness of the body might be, still, if that quickness were not equal
to an infinite quickness the doctrine of Transubstantiation could not be
proved. For, some interval of time (if the velocity be not equal to
infinite) must exist between the body of our Saviour being here, being in
France, being in America, and in a thousand other places, which is
contrary to Roman Catholic doctrine; which asserts, “that as long as the
species of bread and wine continues, so long does Christ exist in the
sacrament;” which words clearly prove, that our Saviour’s body is not to
leave the sacrament at any time, and, therefore, such a supposition of
quickness being attached to the body of Christ, is perfectly absurd and
contradictory to Roman Catholic doctrine.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account