Reasons for Leaving the Church of RomeNolan, Laurence J.
Religion
Reasons for Leaving the Church of Rome
Nolan, Laurence J.
Anglican converts; Catholic Church -- Controversial literature -- Protestant authors; Catholic Church -- Ireland -- Clergy
There are also innumerable passages in the New Testament, where the word
_is_ must be taken to signify represent. First, St. Paul, speaking of
the church, says, “it is the body of Christ.” Here the word _is_ must be
taken to signify represent. In the 13th chapter of Matthew, our Saviour
says, in the 37th verse—“He that soweth the good seed is the son of man.”
Again, in the 38th verse of same chapter he says, “the field is the
world;” and in the 39th verse of same chapter he says, “the harvest is
the end of the world;” and lastly, in Luke viii. 11, our Saviour says,
“the seed is the word of God.” Now, as in all those passages the word
_is_ must be taken to signify represent, what is to prevent it being
taken in the same sense in Luke xxii. 19, where our Saviour said, “this
is my body?”—especially as in the following verse of the same chapter it
must be taken for represent, where our Saviour says, “This cup is the New
Testament;” for the cup was not transubstantiated into the New Testament,
as you must all admit; and therefore it is that I was led to consider
that the word _is_, in the 19th verse of the 22d chapter of Luke, should
be taken in a figurative sense; especially as in that same verse our
Saviour said, “Do this in remembrance of me.” And finally, there is
nothing so common in our language as to make use of this word _is_ in the
sense of represent. For example, let me suppose that on passing through
Sackville-street, in Dublin, and that a stranger on seeing Nelson’s
pillar would ask me, who is that?—I, immediately understanding him, would
say, that is Nelson: and certainly the word _is_, in those passages, must
be taken to signify represent; for which reason, also, I was led to
consider that the word _is_, in this passage of our Saviour, must be
taken to signify represent, when he said, “This is my body.”
I know, my friends, that in opposition to these passages to which I have
alluded, that you would introduce as an objection that passage in the
first of the Corinthians, xi. 27, where it is mentioned, “Wherefore,
whosoever shall eat this bread and drink this cup of the Lord unworthily,
shall be guilty of the body and blood of the Lord;” from which words you
would wish to prove that the Apostles believed the real body and blood of
Christ to be in the sacrament.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account