Reflections on the painting and sculpture of the Greeks : $b with instructions for the connoisseur, and an essay on grace in works of artWinckelmann, Johann Joachim
Philosophy
Reflections on the painting and sculpture of the Greeks : $b with instructions for the connoisseur, and an essay on grace in works of art
Winckelmann, Johann Joachim
Aesthetics -- Early works to 1800; Art -- Philosophy; Art, Greek
Another represents the conclusion of the peace. Holland, though with-held
by the Imperial Eagle, snatching her robe, runs to meet peace, descending
from heaven, surrounded by the Genii of gaiety and pleasure, scattering
flowers all around her. Vanity, crowned with peacocks feathers;
endeavours to with-hold Spain and Germany from following their associate:
but perceiving the cavern where arms are forged for France and Holland,
and hearing same threatening in the skies, they likewise follow her
example. Is not the former of these two performances comparable, in
sublimity, to the Neptune of Homer, and the strides of his immortal
horses?
But let examples be never so striking, allegory will still have
adversaries: they rose in times of old, against that of Homer himself.
There are people of too delicate a conscience, to bear truth and fiction
in one piece: they are scandalized at a poor river-god in some sacred
story. Poussin met with their reproaches, for personifying the Nile
in his Moses[288]. A still stronger party has declared against the
obscurity of allegory; for which they censured, and still continue to
censure, Le Brun. But who is there so little experienced as not to know,
that perspicuity and obscurity depend often upon time and circumstances?
When Phidias first added a tortoise[289] to his Venus, ’tis likely that
few were acquainted with his design in it, and bold was the artist who
first dared to fetter her: time, however, made the meaning as clear
as the figures themselves. Allegory, as Plato says[290] of poetry in
general, has something enigmatick in itself, and is not calculated for
the bulk of mankind. And should the painter, from the fear of being
obscure, adapt his performance to the capacity of those, who look upon
a picture as upon a tumultuous mob, he might as well check every new
and extraordinary idea. The design of the famous Fred. Barocci, in his
Martyrdom of St. Vitalis, by drawing a little girl alluring a magpye
with a cherry, must have been very mysterious to many; the cherry[291]
alluding to the season, in which that saint suffered.
The painting of the greater machines, and of the larger parts of publick
buildings, palaces, &c. ought to be allegorical. Grandeur is relative to
grandeur; and heroick actions are not to be sung in elegiack strains. But
is every fiction allegorical in every place? The Venetian Doge might as
well pretend to enjoy his superiority in _Terra firma_. I am mistaken if
the Farnesian gallery is to be ranked among the allegorical performances.
Nevertheless Annibal, perhaps not having it in his power to choose his
subject, may have been too roughly used in my treatise: it is known that
the Duke of Orleans desired Coypel to paint in his gallery the history
of Æneas[292].
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account