Reflections on the painting and sculpture of the Greeks : $b with instructions for the connoisseur, and an essay on grace in works of artWinckelmann, Johann Joachim
Philosophy
Reflections on the painting and sculpture of the Greeks : $b with instructions for the connoisseur, and an essay on grace in works of art
Winckelmann, Johann Joachim
Aesthetics -- Early works to 1800; Art -- Philosophy; Art, Greek
There are poems of his published, and in manuscript, that abound in
meditations on sublime beauty: but you look in vain for it in his
works.—Beauty, even the beauty of a God, wants Grace, and Moses, without
it, from awful as he was, becomes only terrible. Immoderately fond of
all that was extraordinary and difficult, he soon broke through the
bounds of antiquity, grace, and nature; and as he panted for occasions
of displaying skill only, he grew extravagant. His lying statues, on
the ducal tombs of St. Lorenzo at Florence, have attitudes, which life,
undistorted, cannot imitate: so careless was he, provided he might dazzle
you with his mazy learning, of that decency, which nature and the place
required, that to him we might apply, what a poet says of St. Lewis in
hell:
_Laissant le vray pour prendre la grimace,_
_Il fut toujours au delà de la Grace,_
_Et bien plus loin que les commandements._
He was blindly imitated by his disciples, and in them the want of Grace
shocks you still more: for as they were far his inferiors in science,
you have no equivalent at all. How little _Guilielmo della Porta_, the
best of them all, understood grace and the antique, you may see in that
marble groupe, called the Farnese-bull; where Dirce is his to the girdle.
_John di Bologna_, _Algardi_, _Fiammingo_, are great names, but likewise
inferior to the ancients, in Grace.
At last _Lorenzo Bernini_ appeared, a man of spirit and superior talents,
but whom Grace had never visited even in dreams. He aimed at encyclopædy
in art; painter, architect, statuary, he struggled, chiefly as such,
to become original. In his eighteenth year he produced his Apollo and
Daphne; a work miraculous for those years, and promising that sculpture
by him should attain perfection. Soon after he made his David, which
fell short of Apollo. Proud of general applause, and sensible of his
impotency, either to equal or to offuscate the antiques; he seems,
encouraged by the dastardly taste of that age, to have formed the
project of becoming a legislator in art, for all ensuing ages, and he
carried his point. From that time the Graces entirely forsook him: how
could they abide with a man who begun his career from the end opposite
to the ancients? His forms he compiled from common nature, and his ideas
from the inhabitants of climates unknown to him; for in Italy’s happiest
parts nature differs from his figures. He was worshipped as the genius of
art, and universally imitated; for, in our days, statues being erected to
piety only, none to wisdom, a statue _à la Bernini_ is likelier to make
the kitchen prosper than a Laocoon.
From Italy, reader, I leave you to guess at other countries. A celebrated
_Puget_, _Girardon_, with all his brethren in _On_, are worse. Judge
of the connoisseurs of France by _Watelet_, and of its designers, by
_Mariette_’s gems.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account