Religious PerplexitiesJacks, L. P. (Lawrence Pearsall)
Religion
Religious Perplexities
Jacks, L. P. (Lawrence Pearsall)
Apologetics; Psychology, Religious
Whoever embarks on the task of religious inquiry, which is tantamount
to inquiry into the meaning of his life--a question he would have no
interest in asking unless he were fundamentally a religious
being,--whoever embarks on this task will find the ground encumbered
with a multitude of preconceptions which warp the mind at every point
and render independent judgment extremely difficult. Unless the
inquirer keeps a watch upon himself his mind will run in a groove from
the outset. And when he has followed his groove as far as it goes and
found _nothing_ at the end of it, he will conclude that religion has
broken down. But in nine cases out of ten he will perceive, if he
reflects on what has happened, that the groove which has led to this
result was cut by minds not primarily interested in religion but bent
on protecting some quite alien interest, possibly a vested interest,
institutional or political, to which religion had proved itself
serviceable.
The most obstinate of these misconceptions, and the deepest of the
grooves in which they run, are those connected with the term "God."
There is no worldly interest which has not been anxious to secure God
for an ally. In all ages the attempt has been made to domesticate the
idea of God to the secular purposes of individuals and of groups. If
we examine the current forms of the idea we may observe the marks of
this domesticating process at many points. For example, the idea of
God as the sovereign potentate, governing the universe under a system
of iron law, the legislator of nature and the taskmaster of the soul,
the rewarder of them that obey and the punisher of them that disobey,
is plainly an idea borrowed from politics, the form of the idea most
convenient to those who need God as an ally in the maintenance of law
and order as they conceive them.
This does not prove the idea untrue to reality; it may conceivably be
used as a strong argument to the contrary. At the same time it puts us
on our guard, warning us to look out for other forms of "domestication"
which may be less in accord with essential truth than the one I have
just mentioned. Certainly it is extremely difficult to find any form
of the idea of God which has retained a purely spiritual or religious
character throughout the entire course of its history. Between the
conception of Deity implied in the teachings of Jesus and the
conception as it appears in "God save the King" the distance is
immense; and few theologians I imagine would be so hardy or so
patriotic as to affirm that the latter conception is nearer to the
Divine Reality.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account