Research methods in ecologyClements, Frederic E. (Frederic Edward)
Science
Research methods in ecology
Clements, Frederic E. (Frederic Edward)
Plant ecology; Plant ecology -- Methodology
=32. The value of meteorological methods.= At the outset there must be a
very clear understanding that weather records and readings have only a
very general value. This is in spite of the fact that the instruments
employed are of standard precision. An important reason for this lack of
value is that readings are not made in a particular habitat; as a rule,
indeed, they are made in towns and cities, and hence are far removed
from masses of vegetation. They are usually taken at considerable
heights, and give but a general indication of the conditions at the
level of vegetation. The chief difficulty, however, is that the factors
observed at weather stations—temperature, pressure, wind, and
precipitation—are those which have the least value for the ecologist. It
is true that a knowledge of the temperature and rainfall of a great
region will afford some idea of the general character of its vegetation.
A proper understanding of such a vegetation is, however, to be gained
only through the exact study of its component formations. Ecology has
already incurred sufficient censure as a subject composed of very
general ideas, and the use of meteorological data, which can never be
connected definitely with anything in the plant or the formation, should
be discontinued. This must not be understood to mean that meteorological
instruments can not be used in the proper place and manner, i. e., in
the habitat.
=33. Habitat determination.= It is self-evident that determinations of
factors by instruments can only be of value in the habitat where they
are made. In other words, a habitat is a unit for purposes of measuring
its factors, and measures of one habitat have no exact value in another.
This fact can not be overstated. Thus, while it is perfectly legitimate,
and indeed highly desirable, to locate thermographs in different
mountain zones for ascertaining the rate at which temperature decreases
with altitude, the data obtained in this way are not directly applicable
in explanation of plant or formation changes, except when the same
species occurs at different altitudes. Special methods are valuable and
often absolutely necessary, but in view of the fact that the plant as
well as the formation is the definite product of a definite habitat, the
fundamental rule in instrumentation is that complete readings must be
made within a habitat for that habitat alone. This necessarily
presupposes a certain preliminary acquaintance with the habitat to be
investigated, as it is imperative that the station for making readings
be located well within the formation, in order to avoid transition
conditions. In vegetation, there are as many habitats as formations, and
in addition a large number of new and denuded habitats upon which
successions have not yet started; a knowledge of each formation or
succession must rest ultimately upon the factors of its particular
habitat.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account