Rev. T. Connellan, to his dearly beloved brethren, the Roman Catholics of the diocese of ElphinConnellan, Thomas
Religion
Rev. T. Connellan, to his dearly beloved brethren, the Roman Catholics of the diocese of Elphin
Connellan, Thomas
Catholic Church -- Controversial literature; Catholic ex-priests -- Ireland
But we do not keep a memento of a person, no matter how dear,
who is bodily present. It is only when the friend is really departing
that he leaves a memorial. Jesus, in John (xiv. 2, 3), says, “I go to
prepare a place for you. I will come again, and will take you to myself,
that where I am, you also may be.” Why did not Christ say, “Do not be
troubled. I am leaving myself in the Eucharist. You can handle me, feed
on me. I shall be a thousand times more intimately connected with you
than ever before.” He says nothing of the kind, however. Nor does St.
Peter in his famous sermon (Acts iii. 20) at Solomon’s porch; but he
says, “When the times of refreshment shall come, He shall send Jesus
Christ, whom heaven indeed must receive until the times of the
restitution of all things.”
4. I should be sorry to weary you, and so the last point I shall discuss
here is the alleged primacy of jurisdiction given by Christ to St. Peter,
and through him to the Pope. The chief text upon which the Roman
Catholic Church relies in this matter is Matt. xvi. 18—“And I say to
thee, That thou art Peter and upon this rock I will build my Church, and
the gates of hell shall not prevail against it.” In a note in the Douay
Testament we are told that Christ’s words were the same as if He said in
English, “Thou art a rock, and upon this rock I will build my Church.”
But it is very remarkable that the Evangelist uses the word Petros for
Peter, and Petra for the rock. Now Petros means a stone, while Petra
means a rock; so that the words of Christ would really signify “thou art
a stone, and upon this rock I will build my Church.” If Christ intended
to found His Church upon Peter, He surely would have said, “Thou art
Peter, and upon _thee_ I will build my Church.” But He really does say,
thou art Peter (that is a stone), and upon this rock (Petra) I will build
my Church. Peter certainly was a stone in the edifice equally with the
other Apostles, for St. John in the Apocalypse (xxi. 14) tells us that
the wall of the new Jerusalem “had twelve foundations, and in them the
names of the twelve Apostles of the Lamb.” St. Augustine distinctly
states that Christ is the rock—“Because I am Petra, a rock, thou art
Petrus, Peter; for Petra, the rock, is not from Petrus, Peter; but
Petrus, Peter, is from Petra the rock. And upon this rock I will build
my Church; not upon Peter, whom thou art, but upon the rock whom thou
hast confessed” (tom, v., 1097). St. Jerome holds the same opinion. But
the Church of Rome says Christ gave Peter the keys (Matt. xvi. 19). No
doubt; and Peter admitted the Jews by the doors of the Church (Acts ii.
41), and afterwards the Gentiles (Acts x.). He also gave him power to
bind and loose, and bestowed exactly the same power on the other Apostles
(Matt. xviii. 18). But even if Christ had conferred upon Peter this
extraordinary power, it would not follow that it has been transmitted to
the Pope. They tell us that St.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account