Rocks and Their OriginsCole, Grenville A. J. (Grenville Arthur James)
Science
Rocks and Their Origins
Cole, Grenville A. J. (Grenville Arthur James)
Rocks
Two other views are of course possible. If the composition of the
globe was originally uniform, the two magmas must have arisen by
separation from one of intermediate nature. Hence, in any cauldron in
the crust, in place of one of two magmas, an intermediate magma may
be presumed to exist, and to split up, from various causes, into a
number of parts which are separately erupted at the surface. Charles
Darwin's[78] remarks as to the sinking of crystals in a cooling magma,
and the consequent production of a trachytic and basaltic type in
the same cauldron, led the way to a general acceptance of the theory
of _magmatic differentiation_ in laccolites and batholites. W. C.
Brögger's[79] brilliant explanation of the variation and succession of
types of igneous rock in the Christiania district has had a profound
influence on workers in other fields, and has perhaps directed
attention away from the parallel possibilities of differentiation by
assimilation.
The _assimilation theory_ provides the second possible view above
referred to. A magma may be modified by the rocks into which it
intrudes, so that a "basic" fluid may become charged with silica from
a sandstone, the product crystallising as a granite; while an "acid"
fluid may become so charged with limestone that diorite ultimately
results. A. Harker[80] has discussed both theories clearly, with a
strong leaning to the acceptance of magmatic differentiation in the
cauldron as the only important cause of variation. R. A. Daly, on the
other hand, goes at least as far as Lacroix in France in supporting
the theory of assimilation. For him, the primitive igneous magma is
already basic, and basalts are therefore the prevalent type of igneous
rock. They reach us, moreover, from considerable depths. The acid
rocks are formed by amalgamation of this magma with siliceous material
lying nearer the earth's surface. Igneous rocks exceptionally rich in
alkalies, the so-called "alkaline" series, result from the absorption
of limestone in the magma; denser lime-bearing silicates are thus
formed, which sink by gravitation, leaving a lighter magma above in
which soda has become concentrated. Carbon dioxide liberated from the
limestone also plays a part in carrying up the alkalies that might
otherwise remain in a lower portion[81].
E. H. L. Schwarz[82] extends Daly's views with an almost romantic
fulness. He holds, with Chamberlin, that the primitive globe resulted
from the aggregation of basic meteoritic material. The more siliceous
crust arose from the withdrawal of magnesium and iron into the depths
by long-continued processes of leaching and gravitation. The melting of
this crust produces the acid igneous rocks. Igneous cauldrons originate
in the heat due to faulting, or to crumpling, or even to the impact
of gigantic meteorites. When a molten magma is locally established,
variation occurs in it by assimilation of different types of material
round it.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account