English essays -- 20th century; Russia; Russia -- Fiction; Russia -- Social life and customs; Short stories, English
Another slight episode which gave me food for reflection happened
in the train on a small line between the town of Kharkov and a
neighbouring village. I was going to the town of Kharkov for the day;
it was only half an hour’s journey. I was in a third-class carriage;
there were not many passengers, and most of them were railway guards
off duty, two peasants, a soldier, and a monk. The monk had no sooner
entered the carriage than he began a theological discussion. Now, as
soon as the train started, although I was sitting quite close, I could
not unfortunately follow the intricacies of his argument for the noise
made by the train, but whenever the train stopped at a station his
words were plain. And the drift of the matter was this: that all the
passengers in the carriage were uniting to express to him in forcible
language that priests in general, and monks still more (and himself in
particular), were lazy, worthless, good-for-nothing scoundrels, and
deceivers into the bargain. The soldier said, and his words received
universal approval, that every one who was not a born fool knew that
there was one God, the same for everybody, and that all men were
equal before Him, and that consequently there could be only one real
religious faith (namely, a belief in God), and that all the rest was
the invention of priests. By “the rest” it subsequently became plain
that he meant the Devil and the tenets of the Orthodox Church in
general and of any other Churches. The monk, on the other hand, said
that the Devil was intensely real, and that every man was followed by
angels, who were constantly fighting the Devil for the soul of the
man. Now, the soldier, and three guards off duty who were taking part
in this discussion, starting from the premise that there is only one
God, one faith which consists in the belief in this one God, and that
all priests are liars, worried the monk with questions and attacked
him in every possible manner. They accused him of begging in the first
place; they would be ashamed of doing such a thing, they said. Then
the soldier asked him if he had seen the Devil. The monk said, “Yes,
often.” “Where is he?” said the soldier. “It would be most interesting
to see him.”
Then when the monk stood up for the Orthodox faith the soldier said:
“You say it is the only faith. You lie, because I have been told there
are any number of other Churches, and each of them says its faith is
the true one. For instance, the Jews have an entirely different faith,
and this proves that all priests are liars; because God is the same for
everybody.”
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account