Saint Joan : $b A chronicle play in six scenes and an epilogueShaw, Bernard
HistoryHistory
Saint Joan : $b A chronicle play in six scenes and an epilogue
Shaw, Bernard
Christian women saints -- Drama; France -- History -- Charles VII, 1422-1461 -- Drama; Joan, of Arc, Saint, 1412-1431 -- Drama
The point need be no further labored. Joan was persecuted essentially as
she would be persecuted today. The change from burning to hanging or
shooting may strike us as a change for the better. The change from
careful trial under ordinary law to recklessly summary military
terrorism may strike us as a change for the worse. But as far as
toleration is concerned the trial and execution in Rouen in 1431 might
have been an event of today; and we may charge our consciences
accordingly. If Joan had to be dealt with by us in London she would be
treated with no more toleration than Miss Silvia Pankhurst, or the
Peculiar People, or the parents who keep their children from the
elementary school, or any of the others who cross the line we have to
draw, rightly or wrongly, between the tolerable and the intolerable.
Joan not tried as a Political Offender.
Besides, Joan’s trial was not, like Casement’s, a national political
trial. Ecclesiastical courts and the courts of the Inquisition (Joan was
tried by a combination of the two) were Courts Christian: that is,
international courts; and she was tried, not as a traitress, but as a
heretic, blasphemer, sorceress and idolater. Her alleged offences were
not political offences against England, nor against the Burgundian
faction in France, but against God and against the common morality of
Christendom. And although the idea we call Nationalism was so foreign to
the medieval conception of Christian society that it might almost have
been directly charged against Joan as an additional heresy, yet it was
not so charged; and it is unreasonable to suppose that the political
bias of a body of Frenchmen like the assessors would on this point have
run strongly in favor of the English foreigners (even if they had been
making themselves particularly agreeable in France instead of just the
contrary) against a Frenchwoman who had vanquished them.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account