Sarah Winnemucca's Practical Solution of the Indian Problem: A Letter to Dr. Lyman Abbot of the "Christian Union"Peabody, Elizabeth Palmer
History
Sarah Winnemucca's Practical Solution of the Indian Problem: A Letter to Dr. Lyman Abbot of the "Christian Union"
Peabody, Elizabeth Palmer
Indians of North America -- Education; Paiute Indians -- Education; Winnemucca, Sarah, 1844?-1891
“Two or three weeks since, a fellow named J. W. Scott, who pretends
to be acting for the Interior Department, arrived here from Oregon.
His threats created considerable alarm among the Indians, who
congregated here from all parts of the country to hear what he had
to say. Natches and Winnemucca say that at the time of the outbreak
at the Malheur Reservation, a year ago last summer, this man Scott,
who they state had a beef contract at the reservation, had a talk
with the Indians at Crowley’s ranch. They told him that if he would
state their grievances on paper and send the document to Washington,
they would return to the reservation. The chiefs dictated and Natches
interpreted what he should write. When they finished, not having very
much confidence in his integrity, they took the paper from him and
gave it to G. B. Crowley to read. In this way they ascertained that
he had not written what they dictated, and instead of stating the
fact that they were being starved at the reservation and were driven
to desperation by the treatment they received, he painted the Indians
as demons and the agent as an angel. This infuriated the savages, and
Natches and Winnemucca could hardly restrain the reservation Indians
from scalping Scott right then and there. Knowing that he had played
the Indians false at that time, Natches and Winnemucca were afraid
to trust him at the council held here upon his arrival from Malheur
a short time ago, and they asked a few white men--among them the
writer--to be present. What occurred at the council was truthfully
reported in these columns at the time. Scott, it appears, does not
like the truth; so he reported to Natches yesterday that the ‘Silver
State’ stated a few days ago that he (Natches) and Jerry Long, the
interpreter, were the most notorious liars in the country. What
object the fellow could have in telling such a lie to the Indians,
the writer cannot surmise, unless it was for the purpose of making
them distrustful of those who tell the truth about the Malheur
Agency. An acquaintance of many years with many of the Piutes of
Humboldt County warrants the writer in saying that so far as his
experience extends, they are generally truthful and reliable; while
respectable white men who knew Scott in Plumas County, California,
before he went to Malheur, say the records of the courts in that
county will show that decent men testified that they would not
believe him under oath. Surely the Interior Department ought to send
a man with a better reputation as its representative to hold councils
with the Indians, and keep Mr. Scott at Malheur to take the census of
the Indians and make affidavit to the quantity of beef and blankets
distributed at a reservation where there has not been an Indian since
a year ago last June.”
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account