Saratoga National Historical Park, New YorkWilshin, Francis
History
Saratoga National Historical Park, New York
Wilshin, Francis
Saratoga Campaign, N.Y., 1777; Saratoga National Historical Park (N.Y.)
In persisting in the Philadelphia expedition against the advice of
Clinton and other British officers who advised cooperation with
Burgoyne, Howe preferred a plan of campaign which gained the British
nothing to a plan which might well have won them the war. In his defense
later, Howe argued that he had received no order to cooperate with the
northern army; that he had warned Burgoyne not to expect aid from the
south; that his move to Philadelphia had been approved by the King; and
finally that he had advised Clinton to assist Burgoyne. This move of
Clinton’s however, came so late, and with such limited force, as to make
it ineffective.
[Illustration: _This old print, after the famous painting by John
Graham, portrays the burial of General Fraser. The English
historian, Fonblanque, has identified the portrait figures from left
to right as: Earl of Harrington, A.D.C.; General Burgoyne;
Major-General Phillips; Reverend Brudenell; Captain Green, A.D.C.;
Lieutenant Colonel Kingston; Major Fraser; Mr. Wood, Surgeon; Earl
of Balcarres; Major General Riedesel._ Courtesy Life Magazine.]
As if this were not enough, Burgoyne’s position was still further
weakened by the inability of St. Leger to create a proper diversion
along the Mohawk. These blunders and misfortunes, inherently grave as
they were, do not absolve Burgoyne altogether from responsibility for
the failure of the northern campaign. His conduct of the campaign, at
times, lacked forceful initiative and drive, to which were added grave
errors of judgment, the most serious of which, in all probability, was
the poorly planned expedition against Bennington. The imperative orders
given to Burgoyne by British ministers in England, with little leeway to
adjust his plans according to the actual course of events, was another
important cause of the complete failure of the campaign. Sir Guy
Carleton, then Governor of Canada, wrote in 1777: “This unfortunate
event, it is to be hoped, will in the future prevent ministers from
pretending to direct operations of war, in a country at three thousand
miles distance, of which they have so little knowledge as not to be able
to distinguish between good, bad, or interested advices, or to give
positive orders in matters, which from their nature, are ever upon the
change; so that expedience or propriety of a measure at one moment, may
be totally inexpedient or improper in the next.”
[Illustration: _Three examples of the so-called Kentucky Rifle, the
type of weapon carried by most of Morgan’s Corps of riflemen. These
rifled guns were much more accurate than the smooth-bore muskets
used by most of the soldiers on both sides during the American
Revolution._]
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account