Religious disputations -- Fiction; Short stories, Australian
"We cannot know whether the gods exist or do not exist; the matter is
too obscure, and man's life too short. If they exist, it must be in some
manner peculiar to themselves, for we cannot find any trace of their
presence in the world. They are not present to us as objects to be
perceived by the senses; if they move among us at all it is by stealth,
and without leaving so much trace as a ship leaves upon the waves. But
man has always believed that they are close to him, and has come to
imagine them as haunting every green corner of the earth, each well, and
wood, and hill, the blue depths of the sea and the wide regions of the
air. We have a God to preside at our sowing and at our harvest, at our
setting-forth and at our home-coming; there are gods of flocks and
herds, of vineyards and olive groves, of rivers and of the sea. Poetry
has peopled the air with them, and given to Aphrodite a team of
sparrows, and to Hera a team of peacocks, and to grey-eyed Athene an
owl. Indeed, it is strange, so familiar and frequent are they in our
thoughts, that we should ever question their existence; yet the moment
we seek for any tangible evidence of their presence in the world we are
at fault, and the more we consider them the more shadowy and elusive
they become. The whole notion of divinity is constantly changing in our
minds, adapting itself to new conditions of life, varying its form as
our knowledge becomes deeper; but always becoming more spiritual, less
tangible, until it seems to be nothing but that wandering breath which
quickens all things into life.
"At first we imagined the gods as the incarnation of some natural force,
like Aphrodite, the foam-born, whom all living creatures obey; or
Demeter, the Earth-mother, who produces all the fruits and harvests, and
the grass and flowers of the field. Stripped of the mystery and beauty
with which the poets have clothed them, these are but the conditions of
man's life, his begetting and sustenance; we must seek behind them for
that idea of the supreme reason, who is not only the cause but the end
of all things, not only the source of existence but the principle from
which spring our notions of truth, of wisdom, of justice, and all those
ideals which reconcile us to life and bid us hope in the ultimate
realisation of the good. It is not sufficient for us to find a cause
from which existence is derived, for even if that were laid bare to us
we could not find in it our ultimate satisfaction, unless it conformed
to the idea of divinity, which, as Socrates and Euripides have agreed,
is exclusive of all elements of evil. Is it possible to have this
knowledge? There are two insuperable difficulties.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account