Schools of Hellas: An Essay on the Practice and Theory of Ancient Greek Education from 600 to 300 B. C.Freeman, Kenneth J. (Kenneth John)
History
Schools of Hellas: An Essay on the Practice and Theory of Ancient Greek Education from 600 to 300 B. C.
Freeman, Kenneth J. (Kenneth John)
Education, Greek
Then Homer teaches gluttony, by making Odusseus, the wisest of men,
say――
Best thing in life I count it, a heavy-laden board, While in the
goblets ceaselessly the good strong wine is poured.
Still worse are the tales of the lusts of Zeus or of Ares and
Aphrodite, and of the covetousness of the gods.
Gifts win the heart of gods: gifts win the heart of kings.
Nor must the heroes be allowed to blaspheme. “My respect for Homer
makes me shrink from saying it, but it is impious to state or to
believe that Achilles was ready to fight against the river, a god, or
that he dragged Hektor’s body round Patroklos’ tomb or slaughtered
captives upon it, or that he gave to the dead Patroklos the hair which
he had dedicated to the river god Spercheios.”[672] Nor must poets say
that wicked men are enviable, if they are not found out, or that
justice does good to others but is a loss to oneself. On the contrary,
they must invent myths to establish the opposite, whether it be true
or not, because it is profitable.
Plato cares very little for literal truth in mythology; he is only
desirous that the fiction should be improving and in accordance with
sound ethics. It is impossible to know the truth, he thinks, about
things primeval and the gods, so it is necessary to invent stories as
near the truth as possible and such that they will be improving. The
majority of men, as Isokrates also noticed, prefer myths to anything
else; for their intelligence can only grasp ethical and metaphysical
truths when they are embodied in stories and parables and fables.[673]
These fictions, however, are like powerful drugs: their concoction
must only be entrusted to competent hands, or the result will be
deadly. The rulers of the State, the philosophers, must construct the
national mythology, not unskilled and irresponsible persons like
poets.[674] Plato himself gives a good many instances of such
profitable myths; he enshrines in them, as in a popular form, many of
his deepest beliefs, his psychology,[675] his views of the immortality
of the soul,[676] his political theory that all men are not
equal.[677] In his opinion mythology was the proper food for the
unenlightened many who were incapable of philosophic certainty; the
philosopher, by the light of his exact knowledge of ethics and
metaphysics, was to concoct this food.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account