Schools of Hellas: An Essay on the Practice and Theory of Ancient Greek Education from 600 to 300 B. C.Freeman, Kenneth J. (Kenneth John)
History
Schools of Hellas: An Essay on the Practice and Theory of Ancient Greek Education from 600 to 300 B. C.
Freeman, Kenneth J. (Kenneth John)
Education, Greek
But Euripides did not agree with him. He denounces the athletic life
with much vigour.[346] “Of countless ills in Hellas, the race of
athletes is quite the worst.… They are slaves of their jaw and
worshippers of their belly.… In youth they go about in splendour, the
admiration of their city, but when bitter old age comes upon them,
they are cast aside like worn-out coats. I blame the custom of the
Hellenes, who gather together to watch these men, honouring a useless
pleasure.[347] Who ever helped his fatherland by winning a crown for
wrestling, or speed of foot, or flinging the quoit, or giving a good
blow on the jaw? Will they fight the foe with quoits, or smite their
fists through shields? Garlands should be kept for the wise and good,
and for him who best rules the city by his temperance and justice, or
by his words drives away evil deeds, preventing strife and sedition.”
In return for this, the athlete-loving populace, finding their voice
in the popular poet Aristophanes, denounced Euripides and his Sophist
friends for emptying the gymnasia and making the boys desire only a
good tongue, instead of a sound body, turning them into pale-faced,
indoor pedants, fit for nothing but jabbering nonsense. The attitude
of the poet in the _Clouds_ and _Frogs_ is just that of an average
schoolboy discussing a student.
Plato has already been quoted as an authority against the athlete of
his day. In the _Laws_ he rejects every kind of gymnastics which is
not strictly conducive to military efficiency, and, like the Spartans,
condemns the pankration and boxing. Races in the ideal State are to be
run in full armour, and the javelin and spear are to replace the
quoit. It is exactly the position of some moderns, who would
substitute shooting and field-days for cricket and football. The case
against the athletes may be closed with Aristotle’s testimony: he also
condemns the specialisation of the trained professional.[348]
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account