Science and the modern worldWhitehead, Alfred North
Religion
Science and the modern world
Whitehead, Alfred North
Science
In the particular instance of the quotation which I have just made, the
whole passage and the context in which it is embedded, are permeated
through and through by the experimental method, that is to say, by
attention to ‘irreducible and stubborn facts’, and by the inductive
method of eliciting general laws. Another unsolved problem which has
been bequeathed to us by the seventeenth century is the rational
justification of this method of Induction. The explicit realisation of
the antithesis between the deductive rationalism of the scholastics and
the inductive observational methods of the moderns must chiefly be
ascribed to Bacon; though, of course, it was implicit in the mind of
Galileo and of all the men of science of those times. But Bacon was one
of the earliest of the whole group, and also had the most direct
apprehension of the full extent of the intellectual revolution which was
in progress. Perhaps the man who most completely anticipated both Bacon
and the whole modern point of view was the artist Leonardo Da Vinci, who
lived almost exactly a century before Bacon. Leonardo also illustrates
the theory which I was advancing in my last lecture, that the rise of
naturalistic art was an important ingredient in the formation of our
scientific mentality. Indeed, Leonardo was more completely a man of
science than was Bacon. The practice of naturalistic art is more akin to
the practice of physics, chemistry and biology than is the practice of
law. We all remember the saying of Bacon’s contemporary, Harvey, the
discoverer of the circulation of the blood, that Bacon ‘wrote of science
like a Lord Chancellor.’ But at the beginning of the modern period Da
Vinci and Bacon stand together as illustrating the various strains which
have combined to form the modern world, namely, legal mentality and the
patient observational habits of the naturalistic artists.
In the passage which I have quoted from Bacon’s writings there is no
explicit mention of the method of inductive reasoning. It is unnecessary
for me to prove to you by any quotations that the enforcement of the
importance of this method, and of the importance, to the welfare of
mankind, of the secrets of nature to be thus discovered, was one of the
main themes to which Bacon devoted himself in his writings. Induction
has proved to be a somewhat more complex process than Bacon anticipated.
He had in his mind the belief that with a sufficient care in the
collection of instances the general law would stand out of itself. We
know now, and probably Harvey knew then, that this is a very inadequate
account of the processes which issue in scientific generalisations. But
when you have made all the requisite deductions, Bacon remains as one of
the great builders who constructed the mind of the modern world.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account