No line can be drawn between common knowledge of things and scientific
knowledge; nor between common reasoning and scientific reasoning. In
strictness all accurate knowledge is =Science=; and all exact reasoning
is scientific reasoning. The method of =observation= and =experiment= by
which such great results are obtained in science, is identically the
same as that which is employed by every one, every day of his life, but
refined and rendered precise. If a child acquires a new toy, he observes
its character and experiments upon its properties; and we are all of us
constantly making observations and experiments upon one thing or
another.
But those who have never tried to observe accurately will be surprised
to find how difficult a business it is. There is not one person in a
hundred who can describe the commonest occurrence with even an approach
to accuracy. That is to say, either he will omit something which did
occur, and which is of importance; or he will imply or suggest the
occurrence of something which he did not actually observe, but which he
unconsciously infers must have happened. When two truthful witnesses
contradict one another in a court of justice, it usually turns out that
one or other, or sometimes both, are confounding their inferences from
what they saw with that which they actually saw. A swears that B picked
his pocket. It turns out that all that A really knows is that he felt a
hand in his pocket when B was close to him; and that B was not the
thief, but C, whom A did not observe. Untrained observers mix up
together their inferences from what they see with that which they
actually see in the most wonderful way; and even experienced and careful
observers are in constant danger of falling into the same error.
Scientific observation is such as is at once full, precise, and free
from unconscious inference.
Experiment is the observation of that which happens when we
intentionally bring natural objects together, or separate them, or in
any way change the conditions under which they are placed. Scientific
experiment, therefore, is scientific observation performed under
accurately known artificial conditions.
It is a matter of common observation that water sometimes freezes. The
observation becomes scientific when we ascertain under what exact
conditions the change of water into ice takes place. The commonest
experiments tell us that wood floats in water. Scientific experiment
shows that, in floating, it displaces its own weight of the water.
Scientific =reasoning= differs from ordinary reasoning in just the same
way as scientific observation and experiment differ from ordinary
observation and experiment—that is to say, it strives to be accurate;
and it is just as hard to reason accurately as it is to observe
accurately.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account