Second Shetland Truck System ReportGuthrie, William
History
Second Shetland Truck System Report
Guthrie, William
Labor law -- Truck system -- History -- England; Shetland (Scotland) -- History
2479. Do you mean that if you sold Shetland wool to any one who
asked it, you would not have a sufficient supply for your own
trade?-That is one reason; but there is another reason: because it
would be like changing a shilling, for the people know the value of
these things, and they would just pay me for the wool what I paid
for it in cash.
2480. They can get the wool from the same dealers from whom
you buy?-Yes, and of course the price of it is as well known to
them as to me. Another thing is, that if I take a parcel of worsted
of perhaps 600 or 700 cuts, a knitter who wants some of it won't
be pleased unless she gets the very pick of it; and for the very pick
of it she won't give me any more than I had to pay for the whole of
it overhead.
2481. That is substantially what Mr. Laurenson said with regard to
the reason for not selling Shetland wool. He does not sell it
either?-None of the principal dealers sell it. Sometimes some of
the wool is sold to grocers in town who don't deal in shawls, and
the knitters buy it from them.
2482. But if the knitters ask for Shetland wool, and offer cash for
it, is it usual to sell it?-No, except in very exceptional cases; and
you will see that an exception has been made in the case of that
girl Robertson.
[Page 53]
2483. You want to point that out?-Yes; I consider that we dealt
with her in rather an exceptional way.
2484. I see '12 cuts worsted:' is that what you refer to?-There is
more than that in the account. The very first thing is a balance on
worsted from a previous account, of 2s.; then on December 16,
1865, she gets 12 and 16 cuts at the same time, but at different
prices. The 16 cuts are charged at 3d. per cut, which is a kind of
worsted we very seldom sell. Then July 5, 1866, there are 12 cuts;
and in 1868 there are other sales of worsted to her.
2485. Is this a copy from your books of the account with Elizabeth
Robertson?-Yes; exactly.
2486. The crosses on the side show where worsted has been
given?-Yes.
2487. Do these entries refer to Shetland worsted?-I think mostly.
2488. But you say this is an exceptional case?-Yes; it was to
favour her that I did it.
2489. Was there any particular reason for favouring her in that
way?-It was done because I thought she was a needful person,
and she pleaded for it.
2490. Was it that sort of wool that she was in the way of
knitting?-It was that kind she wanted; and although I was not in
the habit of selling it, I gave it to oblige her.
2491. Do these entries appear in the ordinary account which you
kept with her as a knitter employed by you?-She was never
employed by me specially.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account